10 Best Spots for Ontario Brook Trout

Having the world record on the resume doesn't hurt. Let's go for a little tour of Ontario's world class brookie hotspots.
English fishing legend Matt Hayes with a trophy Nipigon  brook trout G Ellis photo.JPG

Here are the ten best spots to fish for brook trout in Ontario. 

1. Nipigon System

On July 21, 1915, the world record brook trout was caught in the Nipigon River. Today, people still travel to the region to try and break that record. Lake Nipigon, the headwater of the Nipigon River, remains a remarkably unspoiled place. Some anglers camp and fish around the large islands like Shakespeare and Kelvin. The Nipigon River is broken up by three hydroelectric dams, and each section has brook trout. Below Alexander's dam, the river runs free to Lake Superior. There is much good brook trout water in this section.

2. Lake Superior

Lake Superior has long been a famous destination for brook trout anglers from all over the world. The lake's "coaster brook trout" grow large and provide great sport. Most coaster fishing is centred around Nipigon Bay and the surrounding outer islands. Several hotspots east of Nipigon Bay include Terrace Bay, Rossport, Marathon and Pukaskwa Park. West of Nipigon, there are coasters found in Black Bay, Bays End of Thunder Bay, and Pine Bay near the border.

3. The Winisk River

Winisk River is born at Winisk Lake and runs some 700 km north into Hudson Bay. For the trout angler, gorgeous speckled trout up to 6 pounds lurk in the white water rapids found throughout the river. You need a good guide here, but the trip is spectacular.

brook trout
(Photo credit: Gord Ellis)

4. Algonquin Park

Algonquin Park has more than 1,500 lakes and is home to some very famous brook trout waters. Lakes in the remote sections of the park are difficult to access, so they receive little pressure. There are some truly giant brookies available for those who aren't afraid to lug a canoe and swat a few blackflies.

5. Wawa And Lake Superior Provincial Park

So many lakes, so little time. There are literally dozens of stocked and native brook trout lakes throughout this area. Some of the more remote spots provide world-class brook trout opportunities. Again, the deeper you get back into the park, the better the opportunities.

6. Sutton River

The most remote spot on this list, but maybe the only place on earth where you can catch dozens of 4-pound brook trout in one day. On a dry fly. A bucket list trip that every trout angler should do. Several outfitters service this area.

7. Thunder Bay District

About 75 stocked lakes and a dozen or so lakes with natural reproduction make the Thunder Bay district worth investigating. The easily accessed lakes get worked over, but lakes off the beaten path can provide exceptional fishing and true trophies.

8. Longlac - Geraldton - Greenstone area

The Greenstone region has a lot of really great brook trout opportunities in both its lakes and rivers. Anyone who is willing to look over the stocking lists for the Geraldton/Longlac/Nakina area will be richly rewarded. This region has very high-quality lakes, with relatively light angling pressure, and the stocked brook trout grow large.  What's even more impressive is the handful of lakes that have naturally reproducing brook trout.

Gord Ellis with a monster-size Nipigon Brook Trout. (Photo credit: Gord Ellis)

9. The Albany River Watershed

One of the largest waterways in Ontario, the Albany flows northeast from Lake St. Joseph before emptying its massive contents into James Bay. The Albany is justifiably legendary for its brook trout fishing, and people have been travelling north to fish its waters for years. Monster fish are not common here, but the potential for a true trophy brook trout is very real.

10. Ignace And Area

One of the more unusual scenarios for trophy brook trout in Ontario can be found in the Ignace area of Northwestern Ontario. A bonus of fishing in the Ignace area is that access to almost all the brook trout lakes is relatively good. Several lakes even have enough of a launch to back a small car topper in on a trailer.

About Gord Ellis

Gord Ellis is a lifelong resident of Thunder Bay, Ontario and a full time journalist, broadcaster, professional angler and guide. He is the senior editor of Ontario Out of Doors magazine, Canada's best read fishing and hunting magazine. Gord is a regular on CBC radio's Superior Morning and writes a monthly column on Ontario for the Northern Wilds magazine, in Minnesota. He has written over a thousand feature articles and columns for publications as diverse as Sentier Chasse Peche, in Quebec, the Financial Post and the Globe and Mail. He is a long time member of the Outdoor Writers of Canada and has won better than 25 national awards for his writing and photography. In 2018, Gord was inducted into the Freshwater Fishing Hall of Fame in Hayward, Wisconsin.

Recommended Articles

Beyond the Walleye: Cracking the Code on Timiskaming’s Coffee-Coloured Giants

High-tech sonar and pink lures uncover a world-class smallmouth fishery.

The Pipestone Foursome: Unlocking the Multi-Species Treasure Trove of Cedar Island Lodge

From explosive topwater smallmouth to rare northern largemouth and deep-dwelling lakers, the diversity of Northwest Ontario is put to the ultimate test.

World-Class Fishing and Wild Wonders of Timmins

Where trophy walleye are found within city limits and wilderness adventures include sleeping with the wolves.

Top 5 Flies for Smallmouth Bass

The inside scoop on bass flies from the hosts of The New Fly Fisher.

Algonquin Brook Trout

A Fishing and Canoe Trip on Algonquin's Upper Nipissing River

Catching Ontario Walleye

Pro Tips for Bait and Walley Presentations

Trolling for Walleye

Fishing on Dog Lake, Missanabie, Ontario

Ten Mile Lake Lodge

Enjoy Northern hospitality fishing for splake, brook trout and lake trout

Spring Perch Fishing

Use These Tips on Your Next Ontario Fishing Trip

Speckle Splake Spectacular

Ice Fishing for big Northern Ontario speckled & splake trout.

A Guide to Arriving Prepared for the Longlac Wilds

From choosing the right fly rod to staying comfortable on the trail, these three essentials ensure your DIY adventure is all about the fishing.

Shallow Water Walleye

Learn Tips and Techniques From The Extreme Angler

3 Essentials for Success at Pine Sunset Lodge

Make sure your tackle box and your gear bag are ready for the unpredictable weather and hard-fighting fish of Dinorwic Lake.

Spring Fishing Tips For Any Angler

Increase your chance of fishing success

Big Moose Camp

Big Moose Camp is a four-season resort on Lake Nosbonsing just 3 hours north of Toronto.

A Guide to Fly-in Ontario Lodges

Today’s fly-in fishing vacations are no more expensive than most other getaways.

Discover the 3 Best Bass Fishing Lakes in Ontario

Check out these lakes for hard-fighting smallmouth bass on your next fishing trip to Northern Ontario.

Cracking the Code: How a Finesse Pivot Saved a Fly-In Dream at Buck Lake Lodge

When a massive mayfly hatch threatened to derail the mission, Pete turned to an unlikely bass-fishing staple to haul in trophy-class walleye.

The Eyes Have it

How to Use a Natural Resource as Bait

Ice, Grit, And the Glory of the Kaby Lake Pike

The weather is a relentless challenge and the fish are the ultimate reward.