Multi-Species Fly-Fishing

The Top 5 Flies to Have in Your Fly Box on your next fly fishing adventure to Ontario.

1. Black Woolly Bugger

fly-fishing-1

As any multi-species fly angler can attest, a Woolly Bugger is probably one of the most versatile flies to have in your box. It’s a hot meal ticket for some very sought-after species, such as Smallmouth Bass, Trout, Northern Pike, and even larger panfish! A Black Woolly Bugger takes this a step further, with black being an excellent imitation for leeches, dark-coloured crayfish, and even certain baitfish. Using this dark shade is ideal for overcast conditions or in muddy or tannin-stained waters. Woolly Buggers are excellent as they can be fished in every part of the water column, depending on your fly line, the water temperature, time of year and/or the species you’re targeting. Whether you’re swinging your Woolly Bugger like a streamer, stream fishing it like a nymph, or even using it under a strike indicator, there’s no doubt that you’ll find success with this epically versatile fly.

2. Scotty’s McFly

fly-fishing-2

This fly is truly one of my favourites. The Scotty’s McFly was created by Scott Currie of the town of Massey, located in the Algoma region of Northern Ontario! This is an epic smelt pattern imitation perfect for targeting Smallmouth Bass, Northern Pike, and even landlocked Salmon! Use this streamer with a sink tip, intermediate, or even full sinking fly line to explore every part of the water column.

3. Murdich Minnow

fly-fishing-5

Another excellent smelt imitation, the Murdich Minnow is an excellent streamer to have in your multi-species arsenal. While this fly was originally designed to target stripers on the East Coast, it’s become a fan-favourite of fly anglers everywhere when targeting species such as Smallmouth Bass, Brown Trout, Northern Pike, and even Walleye. Due to the smaller, simpler profile of this baitfish imitation, it works best in clearer water, or when fish are busting bait balls. While this fly can absolutely be effective in most areas of the water column with an intermediate line, I always find the most success when using a floating line. When matched with the floating line, the weight of the fly itself allows it to sit just below the surface of the water- optimal for active, hungry fish.

4. Game Changer

fly-fishing-3

The Game Changer is an excellent fly to use when targeting more predatory species such as Musky and Northern Pike, however, I’ve had success with this pattern when angling for Smallmouth and Largemouth Bass, large Brown Trout, and even Musky! One of the features that make this fly so uniquely versatile is the realistic, articulated movement provided by a series of joints along the shaft! Another plus, these flies are tied with fully synthetic material, which in turn results in the fly becoming less waterlogged, making them incredibly easy to cast. Often designed as a smelt or perch imitation, the Game Changer performs well using virtually any setup, in any environment. Whether you’re fishing light rods and floating line in a river or a full sinking line in your local lake, the Gamer Changer is sure to produce.

5. White Zonker

fly-fishing-4

Another epic streamer fly, the White Zonker is the perfect choice when stream fishing for Trout, in lakes and rivers for both Smallmouth and Largemouth Bass and can even be successful when targeting Salmon and Steelhead. One of the more classic multi-species flies, a White Zonker aims to imitate a variety of baitfish and is an excellent attractor pattern thanks to exaggerated movement in the tail and its shiny, reflective underbelly. This pattern works best in water between two and six feet deep; varying your retrieve and twitching your rod tip to imitate a wounded baitfish is sure to get a reaction.

About Jenna McKeown

Jenna McKeown has loved fishing since she was a young girl. Now as a young adult attending university, she has learned the basics of fly fishing. Like all good anglers, she welcomes instruction and education on all aspects of fly fishing and fish. She hopes to inspire other young girls and women to learn more about fly fishing and the great outdoors. Currently Jenna is attending university to become a teacher focused on one day instructing primary grade students in French. Jenna is a passionate singer, songwriter and guitarist. She produces much of the music used in The New Fly Fisher.

Recommended Articles

Non-Stop Action and Trophy Catches at Timberlane Lodge

With 3,000 miles of shoreline and world-renowned natural reproduction, this 150-mile-long fishery is a must-visit for every serious angler.

Heavy Rods and Heart-Stopping Follows: Fly Fishing for Muskies

An ultimate destination for fly anglers looking to test their gear and grit against the North’s most legendary predator.

Why Anglers Are Falling for Golden Lake in Ontario’s Ottawa Valley

From trophy bass to beachside cottages, Golden Lake blends serious fishing with relaxed cottage life.

Welcome to Wally World

Lake Nipissing is a must-fish destination, putting you right in the heart of the action for post-spawn walleye, pike, and big bass.

Cast Into the Heart of a Walleye Paradise

Experience world-class angling and remote island luxury at the only resort on the pristine waters of Route Lake.

Why Georgian Bay is a Fly Angler’s Final Frontier

Discover how a 75-year-old fishing camp serves as the ultimate basecamp for navigating the transition from river currents to island shoals.

Trade the Signal for the Strike

Why Fly-In Walleye Trips are Ontario’s Ultimate Bucket List Adventure

Smashing Topwater Smallmouth in the Heart of Walleye Country

From spacious, spotlessly clean cottages to aggressive multi-species action.

The Big Bass List: 5 Incredible Hotspots in Northern Ontario

From hidden back bays of Sunset Country to the legendary "wolf packs" of Lake Huron.

True Colours

How important is your lure colour when selecting a bait?

"Bronze Tanks" and Toothy Predators on the Fly

Armed with 7-weights and 9-weights, braving September winds to uncover a fishery where world-class smallmouth and aggressive pike.

Shield Lakes & Rivers

A Million Acres of Water. Where do You Start?

Labour Day Lunkers: Why Fall is the Ultimate Time for Lang Lake Bass

Discover a chain of seven interconnected lakes where the smallmouth are built like footballs and the topwater action remains white-hot well into September.

Big Smallmouth on the Ned Rig

From cozy lakefront cabins to 4-pound bass, Snowshoe Camp Resort is the ultimate Algoma fishing getaway.

Top 5 Flies for Brook Trout

Favourite fly patterns from The New Fly Fisher

Top Ranked Flies For Catching Brown Trout

How to set up a fly rod, pick streamers, and catch some trout.

20 Years With Fish TV!

Fish TV discusses their favourite Ontario catches

Catch, photo, release

Save Your Fishing Memories With These Photo Tips

Best WhiteFish Tactics

In Part Two, Learn Best Rods, Reels and Lure Presentations for Whitefish

Memorable Panfish

Fishing Local Creeks With Shoreline Access