The Eyes Have It

Learn how to use fish eyes as bait on your next ice fishing trip

Spend enough time around ice anglers who fish for walleyes and yellow perch in Northern Ontario and you'll soon find yourself immersed in the ever-persistent debate focused on the best presentation to offer the fish—an artificial lure or live bait.

Well, here is a surprise because many days the answer is neither.

Indeed, we've been enjoying a scorching ice bite this winter for big, beautiful, jumbo yellow perch. Most days it has been hard to catch a striped bandit under a foot in length, with most of the tasty oversized fish averaging between 13 and 14 inches.

That is stout.

yellow perch on ice

And the perch bite has been so knock-on-wood consistently good that most days we've not even targeted their bigger, bolder, beautiful walleye cousins. Seems more than enough nice opal eyes have simply shown up on the ends of our lines, as bonus happen chances.

What we've been using for bait, on the other hand, is something I've relied on since I was a young kid ice fishing for perch on Lake Simcoe's famous Cook's Bay. It is the eye that I have carefully removed from one of the fish that we've already placed on ice.

Carefully pinned to the end of a jig or dangling below a small spoon or jigging minnow, there is absolutely nothing quite like it. It looks, smells, and tastes like what the fish are eating.

eye and lure perch presentation

A good friend, Dr. Bruce Tufts, a fish physiologist at Queen’s University and superb angler, often talks about "super stimuli"—things that make fish flip head-over-heels and open up their mouths wide when they see it.

At the top of the list is an eye.

Indeed, the next time you're wandering down the aisle of your favourite big box tackle shop, take a look at the various crankbaits, jerkbaits, minnow baits, surface lures, and jigs adorning the walls. See how prominent the eyes are in the most popular selling lures?

It is not a coincidence.

The eyes are often the first thing you see. They make the lures come alive, as though they are staring at you as you size them up. Fish see and sense the same thing and it drives them mad.

perch

As a matter of fact, in nature, prey species often sport dark eyespots or "false eyes" on their bodies—usually near their dorsal or tail fins—that confuse predator fish and thwart the attack.

Researchers with Australia’s Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, for example, recently discovered that damselfish not only have the ability to grow larger false eyes on both sides of their bodies near their tails, but they can also shrink the size of their real eyes so as to confuse their predators. Indeed, a predator thinks the damselfish is going to flee in the opposite direction that it actually takes.

Even more amazing, when the scientists donned scuba gear and studied the damselfish on the coral reefs, they found that the ones with enlarged false eyes near their tails were five times more likely to avoid being eaten than the ones with normal size eyespots.

How is that for a brilliant evolutionary adaptation?

And you can use it to your advantage to catch more and bigger walleyes and yellow perch this winter. 

To be sure, when you attach the eye of a perch you've carefully removed from a dead fish that you previously caught, you're giving the predators the perfect target. Only this bull’s eye is surrounded by sticky sharp hooks.

About the only thing you have to be careful about is not puncturing the eye if you use a sharp knife to remove it. I like to carefully run the tip of my Leatherman around and behind the eyeball so the whole thing pops out. When you do it correctly, it will look like a large bead and the tissue at the back of the eye is super tough. So, you can often catch a dozen or more fish on one eyeball.

I should mention, too, that the eye from a walleye works just as well for catching other walleyes. Because it retains the tapetum lucidum, which acts like one of the light-reflecting balls from the bygone disco era, it shines and reflects light, even in the dark in 28 feet of water, allowing other walleyes to zero in on it.

perch and eye lure

Last, but certainly by no means least, some folks might be wondering if it is legal to use perch and walleye eyes as bait, since they have been obtained from a sport fish and the Ontario Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act prohibits the wasting of fish flesh which is suitable for consumption. The good news is that the eyes are not considered flesh, so it is perfectly fine to use them as bait. Indeed, anglers typically discard the heads of walleye and perch after they clean their catch, so you're actually making fuller use of a valuable natural resource.

And that is good, considering most days, the eyes have it.

(All photo credits: Gord Pyzer)
About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Loch Ness Fishing

Loch Island Lodge is an Angler's Dream

Bobber-Whacky Magic

Don't Say Good-bye To The Bobber

Wabigoon Walleye Extreme

Trophy-sized Walleye in the 30" Class

Kashabowie Bass Blast

Fishing for Walleye, Northern Pike and Bass in Ontario's Superior Country

5 Places to Shore Fish

Fish’n Canada shows you where to go shore fishing in Ontario.

Become a World-class Fishing Guide

Misconceptions, behind-the-scenes intel, and key tips from a professional guide.

Lake of the Woods

10 Facts You Didn't Know

Don't Let the Name Perch Lake Fool You

These Northern Ontario waters are packed with northern pike like you'll never believe, abundant gourmet walleye, and yellow perch await.

Pot of Golden Walleye

Fishing at Whitefish Lodge in Ontario's Algoma Country

Muskie Moons

More than just superstition?

Predicting Lake Thickness

When Will Ontario Lakes Freeze Over This Winter?

Lodge 88: Keeping it in the Family

Fish'n Canada host Ang Viola takes his grandson to fly-in fishing lodge Lodge 88 on Esnagi Lake.

Top 5 Flies for Smallmouth Bass

The inside scoop on bass flies from the hosts of The New Fly Fisher.

Exclusive Video

How To Zero In On Lake Trout

Terrestrial Flies for Brook Trout

These fish feed like crazy and look for opportunities for a big protein meal.

Ontario Brown Trout Fishing

It may be the best fishing on earth.

Perfect Shore Lunch

Try This Award-Winning Recipe

Top 10 Ice Fishing Lakes

Every kind of fish and experience—Ontario ice fishing is some of the best in the world.

Best WhiteFish Tactics

In Part Two, Learn Best Rods, Reels and Lure Presentations for Whitefish

5 Deadliest Fishing Lures

Use these lures when ice fishing for lake trout in Northern Ontario.