The Soup Witch
The Soup Witch has become a popular stop for locals and tourists alike. Wanting to know more about thecafé, I arranged to meet up with the owners, Mana and Katrina, one snowy winter day at their café.

A Magical Addition to Sault Ste. Marie’s Food Scene
Mana herself has been working in kitchens for over twenty-five years. "I took culinary arts training at Sault College along with a graphic arts course, and I have always wanted to open my own business," she said. "I was most interested in a casual cafe/diner style eatery, rather than fine dining.” Mana and Katrina have been friends for over twenty years and talked about opening a business together.
With Katrina’s business and community development degrees and a lot of experience in the food industry, they seized on an opportunity during the pandemic. “We both lost our jobs and were looking around for something to do. This space became available for lease, along with the equipment, and we decided to go for it.”
The Soup Witch opened in June 2020. It started as a café but evolved into a grab-and-go, with freezer meals. Customers can dine-in or take-out. About 75% of their business is take-out.

To say that Mana is enthusiastic about her menu is an understatement. She is passionate and shared that some of the menu items playfully use witch-themed names. Here are some of the customers' "witchy" favourites:
Rudy Reuben or Morgana or Joey
Smoked meat, grainy mustard, chipotle aioli, Monterey Jack cheese & sauerkraut SLAW on HOME bakehouse & café’s grilled cheddar dill sourdough. Swap the smoked meat for turkey & make it a Morgana! To make it a Joey, swap the sauerkraut for diced pickles!
The Coven
A take on the classic club with roasted TURKEY, crispy bacon, seasoned tomato slices, pea shoots, Monterey Jack cheese & honey garlic dijonnaise on HOME bakehouse & café’s panini’d rosemary garlic sourdough.
Salem Dog
A jumbo all-beef hot dog grilled & served on a bun topped with bacon, cheddar cheese, dill pickles & yellow mustard.

Seitanic Dog
A jumbo veggie hot dog grilled & served on a bun topped with BBQ braised seitan & pickled red onions.
60+ Soups a Month: Rotating Daily Specials & Comfort Classics
Soups are made daily with a meat and a vegetarian option. Each month, The Soup Witch makes 60 to 70 different kinds of soups, ensuring a variety every day of the week.

Gourmet Sandwiches & Local Ingredients
Sandwiches, including grilled cheese and hot dogs, are made to order with a gluten-free option for no extra charge. They make seasonal sandwiches like the Spring Bog Witch, Summer Banshee, and I’m Melting.
You can also add a salad and a side biscuit. If you’re looking for a delicious drink, hot and cold beverages, like a flavoured cappuccino and a variety of teas, are available. “We like to have fun with our menu. We do a lot of research to get inspiration. Our customers come from the immediate area and those from the ski hills, trails, and parks. We have a big following from those travelling along the Trans-Canada Highway searching for places to eat; the café is not far off Great Northern Road.”

The Soup Witch enjoys getting involved in the community, from the “Fill Our Freezer” benefiting supports like Soup Kitchen Community Centre.
Many of the ingredients for the menu come from Algoma farms and suppliers, like Lock City Dairies, HOME bakehouse & Cafe, The Plant Farm, St. Joseph Island Coffee Roasters and Agawa Fishery

In case you’re wondering: “No, we are not actually witches or Wiccan,” says Mana. “We do respect all beliefs and like to think we are a positive and welcoming place for everyone.” I would add, a wonderful addition to the Sault’s and Algoma’s fantastic food scene!
Plan Your Visit to The Soup Witch
Co-Owners: Mana Goodfellow and Katrina Holkko
215 Fourth Line West, Sault Ste. Marie, ON
PH: 705 759-Soup (7687)
Web: thesoupwitch.com
Facebook: www.facebook.com/TheSoupWitchCafe
Instagram: @thesoupwitchcafe
Check social media for hours of operation!
Check the Menu Ahead of Time: The Soup Witch posts their daily soup and stew lineup on social media the day before.
Seating & Space: The café operates mostly as a grab-and-go counter with limited dine-in seating. Plan your visit with either take-out or plan your dine-in early or during off-peak hours.
Delivery Options: Local delivery is available via SkipTheDishes.
Dietary Inclusivity: There are vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options integrated into the daily soup rotation and sandwich menu, making it accessible for varying dietary needs.
Take-Home Freezer Meals: "Witchy Meals" in the freezer section are stocked with microwave- and freezer-friendly soups, pot pies, mac and cheese, and Pierogi Pies.
Recommended Articles
The Group of Seven in Algoma
9 Facts to Know about the Agawa Canyon Tour Train