Bear Creek Bruisers

Lake Nipissing has a reputation for holding some of the largest muskies in Ontario

For the fishing enthusiasts of the world, Lake Nipissing is synonymous with muskies—big ones. It's big water with big spots, and throughout the musky world, Lake Nipissing has a reputation for holding some of the largest muskies throughout Ontario, Canada. This fall we stayed at Bear Creek Cottages, and once again Lake Nipissing did not disappoint.

Bear Creek Cottages is located in South Bay on Lake Nipissing, which is approximately 3.5 hours north of Toronto and just south of the town of North Bay. When we arrived, and during the first day of filming The Musky Hunter, the conditions were sunny, warm, and flat calm. These conditions were unexpected for Lake Nipissing in the fall, yet they were extremely enjoyable. I was fishing with pro guides Danny Columby and Shawn Degagne, who owns Bear Creek Cottages and also guides on the lake. We fished a series of island and rock humps and managed to catch a couple of nice fish, lose a few and see several. Best of all, with the calm conditions we were able to fish in many different spots throughout South Bay. It was an incredibly enjoyable day on the water.

bear creek cottages lake nipissing

Beautiful Lake Nipissing Sunset at Bear Creek Cottages. (Photo credit: The Musky Hunter)

The next day, Lake Nipissing decided to be its usual self. We had an incoming front with the wind predicted to shift from the south to the north. It was classic musky weather, but we knew that by the end of the day, the wind was supposed to howl and the temperature was going to drop 20 degrees! We dodged some storms and cast several different spots managing to boat a couple of muskies fishing weed beds. However, as the wind picked up, we knew it was time to start trolling. So Danny suggested a prime trolling area, and away we went.

As we awaited the start of a daily moon period, we knew we would get a shot before the winds picked up and the waves got too big. As we trolled across the top of a shallow reef, a rod went off and we caught a nice 44-incher. Confident in the trolling speed and depth, we stuck with the pattern. As we approached another reef, a reel went off. The sound was so loud I initially thought we were snagged, but a quick glance at the depth finder told me it was no snag. I grabbed the rod and I could feel the giant head shakes from the monster musky. The fish rushed the boat and stayed deep. It was a challenge landing the fish in the big waves which had also developed. However, Shawn did an excellent job getting the musky into the net. Within minutes we unhooked, measured, and released the 53-inch, 40-pound class musky. It was an awesome fish to close the episode, and something I will never forget.

Casting or trolling on Lake Nipissing is best around many of the islands and reefs. You’ll find the islands have a variety of rocky points and lush cabbage beds. The shallow reefs are mostly broken rock and can hold muskies all season long. When casting focus on the tops of the rocks, but when trolling, work the edges and the area immediately adjacent to the reefs. Keep fishing a good-looking spot and sooner or later you will contact muskies. As far as lure colours, anything that looks like a perch or walleye is a sure bet. Plus, you can’t go wrong with anything black.

Boating giant muskies from Lake Nipissing is not easy, but it's something I have been fortunate to experience on several occasions. South Bay is known for producing some of the largest muskies on the Lake. Bear Creek Cottages is wind-protected and right next to some of the best musky fishing on the lake. Shawn Degagne is a great host in that he guides and knows the lake extremely well. Both Shawn and guide Danny Columby can really help anyone get dialled into the Lake Nipissing muskies. Bear Creek Cottages has its own boat launch, and a great docking system and the cottages are extremely comfortable. Plus, the sunsets from the beach at the resort are amazing. If you are looking for a relaxing vacation, or better yet a big musky adventure, Bear Creek Cottages on Lake Nipissing is the place to stay.

About Jim Saric

Jim owns Jim Saric Outdoors, Inc., which is dedicated to elevating the sport of musky fishing to new levels by educating anglers through print, web, and television. He is the publisher, editor and owner of Musky Hunter Magazine and the Executive Producer of The Musky Hunter television series. Jim has over twenty-five years experience fishing lakes, rivers, and reservoirs from Minnesota to New York and all across Canada. He has boated more than 100 muskies exceeding 50 inches in length, the largest weighing 53 pounds.

Recommended Articles

Muskie Moons

More than just superstition?

Pot of Golden Walleye

Fishing at Whitefish Lodge in Ontario's Algoma Country

Loch Ness Fishing

Loch Island Lodge is an Angler's Dream

Wabigoon Walleye Extreme

Trophy-sized Walleye in the 30" Class

Big Hook Camps

Walleye and Pike Fishing in Beautiful Canadian Wilderness

Don't Let the Name Perch Lake Fool You

These Northern Ontario waters are packed with northern pike like you'll never believe, abundant gourmet walleye, and yellow perch await.

Bobber-Whacky Magic

Don't Say Good-bye To The Bobber

Ontario Brown Trout Fishing

It may be the best fishing on earth.

Become a World-class Fishing Guide

Misconceptions, behind-the-scenes intel, and key tips from a professional guide.

Kashabowie Bass Blast

Fishing for Walleye, Northern Pike and Bass in Ontario's Superior Country

Exclusive Video

How To Zero In On Lake Trout

Top 10 Ice Fishing Lakes

Every kind of fish and experience—Ontario ice fishing is some of the best in the world.

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

Lake of the Woods

10 Facts You Didn't Know

Shoreline Strategies

Try These 2 Techniques For Targeting Winter Brook Trout

Nipigon Brook Trout

Experience some high caliber Trout Fishing in Northwestern Ontario.

Steelhead of the Upper Ganaraska

Known to most trout and salmon anglers as one of Ontario’s most popular fishing destinations.

Wind, Cloud & Walleye

How Weather is Important to Walleye Anglers

Eagle Lake Island Lodge

Fish for Walleye, Northern Pike, Muskie, Smallmouth Bass, Lakers and Whitefish

Incredible Walleye

Drive-to Fishing at Brennan Harbour Resort