A Black Crappie to Remember

Panfish can be a joy to catch even on a local creek with only shoreline access.

*Originally published on April 20, 2016

When it comes to panfish, there’s only been one so far that has given me the shakes. You know, the feeling of adrenaline and excitement that is only caused by a big fish? Although I’m talking about a panfish here, this one black crappie holds a memory that will forever stick in my mind. Maybe it’s because black crappie are my favourite amongst panfish, or because it was a fish that almost got away. Or maybe even the fact that it took me some effort to get this one to bite at all. In the end, any personal best creates a memory and motivation to catch an even bigger one! Here’s the story of my personal best black crappie, caught last spring.

I had found a small creek connected to a lake near my house that I was able to access only from the shore. It was very narrow and too shallow in some areas for a boat to get into. Even a canoe or a kayak would be overkill for this creek. It was about 8 to 10 feet wide, winding, rugged, and about 3 - 4 feet deep at the very most. It was shallow, with a dark bottom, and surrounded by old reeds and brush. A beaver built a house there, so there were plenty of submerged sticks and trees in the area for fish to hold on. This made for a great environment for crappie to move in, eat, and spawn.

creek shoreline
(Photo credit: Ashley Rae)

Now, this wasn’t a super early season spot, as the crappie moved in here a little later than other areas I’d fished. It was still holding a lot of crappie, though, and some bluegill and pumpkinseed as well. I’d caught loads of spring crappie up until this point and was on the hunt for a personal best. This was the type of spot that it was best to creep up to, as the fish could spot you and spook away pretty easily. One afternoon, I was scoping out the creek and spotted, through the murky water, a large crappie hovering around a stump. It looked like a nice fish from what I could tell, even through the stained water. I snuck up on this fish and worked a white 1-inch tube under a float right up to it. No interest. It took me what felt like forever (around 10 minutes) of trying various techniques and presentations until I was finally able to get this fish to bite. It seemed to prefer a slow-moving presentation. It was a big crappie!

Normally, I always have a net, as this spot especially had a really rugged shoreline that wasn’t always easy to land a fish. Of course, the net was forgotten on this day. I hollered at my fishing partner when I hooked into the fish finally, and he ran over only to realize we had no net, but still tried to help me land this fish anyway. I didn’t want to crane this fish over the brush, but before I could give it much thought, Eric jumped into the cold spring water to grab my fish. And then he dropped it!

(Photo credit: Ashley Rae)

This is the point where we both felt sick and panicked at the thought that this giant crappie was lost. A second or two later, we realized that lo and behold, the fish was still on! The brush on the shoreline kept the fish pinned and hooked for a few seconds until Eric reached down and grabbed it again. Phew! I think my shaking started long before this moment, but it was then that I could feel it the most. After some celebrating, we placed the fish in a bucket full of water briefly to get the camera ready for some pictures.

To date, this is the most exciting black crappie moment I’ve had, and this fish measured at nearly 14 inches in length. I know they certainly get much bigger, but this is my current personal best. After a few quick photos, this fish was released to live and breed. Hopefully, I’ll find it again this year, maybe even on the same stump. Hopefully, it’s gained some length and a new personal best is in store for me!

About Ashley Rae

Ashley Rae is a year-round multi-species angler residing in Ottawa, Ontario. She is a full-time fishing writer and content creator. Ashley is passionate about chasing anything with fins from her boat, kayak, from shore, or on the ice

Recommended Articles

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

Birchland Cottages: Modern comfort with classic Northern Ontario charm

This Clear Lake gem is a great for kids, and the fishing action is non-stop.

Striker's Point Lodge

Hungry Walleyes and Big Pike on Whitewater Lake

10 Facts About Lake of the Woods

10 facts amazing about this massive Northwest Ontario Lake!

Eagle Lake Fall Muskies

Discover why in the late fall Eagle Lake is a prime location to catch giant muskies in Sunset Country.

Ontario Experience

Drive-to Fishing at Waterfalls Lodge

Ten Mile Lake Lodge

Enjoy Northern hospitality fishing for splake, brook trout and lake trout

Year Round Fishing in Ontario

Who Says You Can’t Fish All Year in Ontario?

Angling the Missinaibi

Exploring and fishing the mighty Missinaibi River

Adventures on the Nipigon River

Anglers can target Chinook Salmon and Steelhead in this body of water—but most come for the trophy Brook Trout.

Top 5 Flies for Smallmouth Bass

The inside scoop on bass flies from the hosts of The New Fly Fisher.

Eating Northern Pike

The Best Recipe to Cook This Fish

Choose your Fishing Adventure: 39 Lodges Accessible by Train, Plane, Boat, and Automobile in Ontario

How will you explore the province's waterways this upcoming season?

5 Reasons To Go Fishing In The Fall

Tips for catching Ontario trophies.

Horwood Lake Lodge

Summertime Bass and Walleye from Horwood Lake in Northeastern Ontario

Pleasant Cove Resort

Setting sights on Georgian Bay Northern Pike

Reid's Birch Island Resort

Drive-to Fishing in a Remote Setting

Baptiste Bass

Catching 5- to 6-Pound Smallmouth Bass Each Fishing Season

St. Francis Titans

Fishing the Original Muskie Capital of the World

Hand to Hand Combat

Experience Crappie Fishing in Ontario