A Lake with Options

Getting to Northeastern Ontario’s Lady Evelyn Lake is part of the whole experience.

Temagami is quintessential Northern Ontario. I’m talking legendary fishing, rugged terrain, pristine lakes, and old-growth forests -- the likes of which have captured hearts and inspired imaginations for generations. Along the northern periphery of this world-renowned wilderness area, Lady Evelyn is waiting. She’s an angler’s dream; a lake with options, and they all lead to fish.

If your angling style is about the journey, then Lady Evelyn is right up your alley. There are no roads in, and getting there is part of the whole experience. You can charter a float plane out of Temagami, or you can opt to have your boat brought over the Mattawapika Dam to enter the lake via the Montreal River. No matter how you get in, you’ll find leaving the hard part.

Where to Stay, Where to Fish?

preacher's point lady evelyn lake
Off Preacher's Point on northeastern Ontario’s Lady Evelyn Lake. (Photo credit: Tanya Van Kempen)

Backcountry campsites dot the shoreline of this lake, making boat camping and canoe tripping great options for anglers. If you are looking for something a little less rustic, then Garden Island Lodge is the way to go. Garden Island is the only lodge on the southern arm of the lake. It features nine cozy cabins, exceptional service, and fantastic food. Start your day right with a fresh cup of coffee and a hot meal prepared and served at the main lodge. Once you’ve had your fill, grab your gear and head down the path to the docks, where a boat waits for your day out on the water. It only gets better from there.

The walleye are plentiful here, and basic knowledge of angling tactics for these golden beauties will take you far. I’ve had success year-round fishing structure, mostly off rocky points, and early in the season, it doesn’t seem to matter what I throw at them. Everything from worm harnesses to coloured jigs tipped with minnows works well from spring through to early summer. Later in the season, trolling slender crankbaits like the original Rapala is a favourite technique. Should you tire of walleye fishing, Lady Evelyn also provides ample opportunities for smallmouth bass and monster northern pike.

ontario walleye lady evelyn lake
Evening's catch: Rebecca Van Kempen with a big walleye from Northeastern Ontario’s lady Evelyn Lake. (Photo credit: Tanya Van Kempen)

You can customize your experience on Lady Evelyn every time by alternating how you go, where you stay, and what you fish. With breathtaking scenery and top-notch fishing, this lake is a guaranteed memory maker.

Recommended Articles

Wild Brook Trout

A Guided Float Trip Down the River

Baptiste Bass

Catching 5- to 6-Pound Smallmouth Bass Each Fishing Season

Pike Aplenty

How to select the right spot to catch pike in late fall fishing in Ontario.

Speck-Tacular

The Dotted Love Affair with Ontario's Brook Trout

Inaugural Fish'n Canada Carp Cup

The Inaugural Canadian Carp Cup was held in Long Sault on the St Lawrence River.

Swim Shiner Swim

What Bait to Use in Cold Water Fishing Conditions

Ladies Walleye Weekend

A 3-day Fishing Adventure on the Bay of Quinte

Witch Bay Camp

Secluded Lake of the Woods Fishing for Walleye and Muskie

Fishing Esnagi Lake

Train-in Fishing at Lodge Eighty Eight

Debunking Muskie Myths

Busting Popular Myths About Ontario's Big Toothy Beasts

Fish on a Fly

Pike and Walleye Fishing on Esnagi Lake

Mammoth Magnets

How Water Temperature Affects Pike & Muskie

Hand to Hand Combat

Experience Crappie Fishing in Ontario

Incredible Walleye

Drive-to Fishing at Brennan Harbour Resort

Planning for Pike

Start Planning for Trophy Fishing

Lake Lauzon with Fish'n Canada

Walleye, Pike, and Smallmouth Bass with some real giants in the mix.

Fly Fishing for Smallmouth Bass Year Round

A drive-to cottage resort where the smallmouth fishing is second to none.

5 Keys To Canadian Muskies

The fish of 10,000 casts; an elusive predator fish with legend and lore.

Sun Trout and Ice

Algoma's Elliot Lake for days of Sun and catching Trout on the Ice.

Fishing the Exceptional Waters at Blue Fox Camp

Incredible Brook Trout Fishing is just a flight away in the heart of Algoma Country.