Debunking Muskie Myths Part 2

Busting myths that can hinder an angler's quest for the toothy beast

In last week's blog, I discussed with Ontario muskie guru, Wally Robins, and Ottawa Muskie Factory owner and guide, John Anderson, the many ways that muskie folklore hinders anglers in their quest to catch Northern Ontario's top predator.

This week, let's finish the conversation and blow some more muskie myths out of the water, making it easier for anglers to fulfill their dreams.

"Too many folks believe you have to use big baits all the time to catch muskies," says Robins, "but it is not true. This might be my favourite muskie myth to attack and for good reason. Talk to smallmouth and walleye anglers who fish muskie lakes in Northern Ontario and you will hear endless stories about the big toothy critters they caught on 1/4-ounce jigs tipped with 3-inch grubs and traditional bass-size jerk baits."

john anderson holding ontario muskie

John Anderson says most anglers could fish the entire season with two dozen carefully selected muskie lures. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

"I have to tell you, too, that one of my favourite surface lures for muskies is a Top Raider. It is exactly 5 1/2 inches long. Compare that to the famous Zara Spook bass lure that is 4 1/2 inches long. Are you going to tell me that one-inch matters?"

"In fact, in the cold water period of late fall, one of my go-to presentations for big muskies is using a 3/4-ounce flipping jig with a 6-inch shad trailer. You fished with me a couple of years ago, Gord, and caught a gorgeous muskie on a 5-inch Bass Magnet Tubezilla. So, yes, big baits catch big muskies, but so do smaller ones. And at certain times of the year, like right now, smaller lures are often better."

wally robins holding lure

Wally Robins says it is a mistake to believe you always have to use big baits to catch muskies. He often flips bass-size tube jigs in the fall. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

One of John Anderson's favourite fables, on the other hand, is the one that suggests that in order to catch a big muskie you need to carry a suitcase-size tackle box filled with baits.

"Let's face it," Anderson chuckles, "I am a lure collector like most muskie anglers. It is fun. But the fact of the matter is that lures are simply tools. When was the last time you saw a carpenter carrying 200 screwdrivers?"

"If I had to, I could probably make do the entire season with two dozen baits."

"And selecting the right ones is a pretty simple system. The way to do it is by picking lures that cover different parts of the water column. For example, I'd recommend an angler get two or three surface baits, and half a dozen in-line spinners with different blade sizes from #7 up to #10. You might even throw in a couple of #12 if you’re really brave. Then, two or three glide baits and jerk baits, half a dozen soft plastic BullDawgs and Shadzillas and a few Bondy Baits and Shadzilla Vs for vertical jigging."

Both Anderson and Robins agree that a benefit of carrying fewer muskie baits is that you will become more proficient much faster with presentations. You quickly learn the intricacies of the lure and how to present it properly, thus catching more and bigger fish.

angler holding muskie

Ottawa River Muskie Factory owner John Anderson keeps his clients happy by helping them become proficient with a few presentations rather than overwhelming them with many. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

You will also develop confidence in the baits and won't get in the rut that Robins calls the endless process of cycling through 25 baits a day looking for the “magic bullet” that doesn’t exist.

And what do our experts have to say about the importance of colour when you're selecting a lure? Well, better hold on.

angler holding muskie

Wally Robins develops confidence in basic bait styles and doesn't worry about finding the magic bait, that he says, doesn't exist. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

"It is an old wives’ tale," chuckles Robins, "probably created by the tackle industry to get us to buy more baits. The reality, however, is that when you're trying to decide what lure to throw for muskies, colour is far behind factors like the depth you want the lure to run, the action you want it to make and the speed with which you want to present it."

"As for the myth that 'any colour is good, as long as it’s black", Anderson chimes in, "I don’t buy it. Black can be an excellent choice, but so can pink, blue, green, brown, chartreuse and white. In fact, if you look at the prey fish that muskies eat, every one of them has a white body tone. It actually surprises me that white is rarely viewed as a good colour choice for muskie baits."

Anderson and Robins also agree that, at least from a colour perspective, “matching the hatch” is an overrated theory. Witness, they say, how eagerly a muskie will eat the brightest, gaudiest lure in your tackle box when their main forage is suckers and bullheads.

gord pyzer holding muskie
Gord Pyzer caught this dandy cold water muskie by scaling down and using a Bass Magnet tube jig. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

"Certain water systems may have colour idiosyncrasies," says Robins, "but for the most part, colour isn’t a major factor. It is a self-fulfilling prophecy. I mean, if muskie anglers on a certain lake swear that the best colour is fire tiger, then that’s what they are going to throw 90-percent of the time. And every fish they catch will 'prove' the point."

That noise you just heard, folks, was Anderson and Robins blowing another muskie myth out of the water.

About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Predicting Lake Thickness

When Will Ontario Lakes Freeze Over This Winter?

10 Facts About Lake of the Woods

10 facts amazing about this massive Northwest Ontario Lake!

Beaded Lures

Find out why these chintzy plastic beads are the perfect lure.

Ontario Fly Fishing Hotspots

The Top 10 List

5 Deadliest Fishing Lures

Use these lures when ice fishing for lake trout in Northern Ontario.

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

Shoreline Strategies

Try These 2 Techniques For Targeting Winter Brook Trout

Mississagi Multi-Species Magic

Equipped for outfitting sportsmen and providing family fishing vacations.

Don’t Be Afraid Of Muskies

Muskies are fish of 10,000 casts and are found in large bodies of water in Northwestern Ontario.

Top 10 Fly Patterns for Brook Trout

Learn Brook Trout Fly Pattern Choices for Surface Fly Fishing

Top 5 Musky Destinations in Ontario

The Musky Hunter shows you where to land the best musky in Ontario waters.

Fishing for Muskie on the French River

Crane's Lochaven Wilderness Lodge

20 Years With Fish TV!

Fish TV discusses their favourite Ontario catches

Do-It-Yourself Fly-In Fishing

Fly into one of nine outpost camps on nine lakes with Lauzon Aviation

Ten Mile Lake Lodge

Enjoy Northern hospitality fishing for splake, brook trout and lake trout

Perfect Shore Lunch

Try This Award-Winning Recipe

Shield Lakes & Rivers

A Million Acres of Water. Where do You Start?

White(fish) North

Ontario's Lakes Offer Unlimited Opportunities

Algonquin Brook Trout

A Fishing and Canoe Trip on Algonquin's Upper Nipissing River

Salmon Fishing

The Michipicoten River is a Sleeper for Chinook