Muskie Hits and Misses

Alyssa has spent the past three years pursuing muskie on the fly. After many flossed fish, it only took one to reach the net to complete her mission. Sort of.

Three years ago I had the bright idea of pursuing, at all costs, a muskie on the fly.

Keep in mind that, at the time, I hadn’t even begun fly fishing when the decision was made to pick up an 11-weight rod and toss gargantuan muskie flies over my head. 100% green as a fly angler, I threw myself into a brand-new world of fishing.

There are a few things one should know before pursuing muskie on the fly. First thing, it is downright dumb to begin learning to fly fish with muskie and pike flies. That may be more obvious to most than it was to me.

With swollen hands, thrown shoulders, and raw stripping creases on my palms, I delved into fly fishing.

setting fly fishing hook
(Photo credit: Alyssa Lloyd)

Obsessed with landing a giant, I travelled across two provinces, three different time zones, and thousands of miles to another coast just to try to land my first muskie on the fly. What is it about anglers that makes us think the best fish are further away? Heck, all of my personal bests have come from the same bays I launch the boat in.

By the way, this was the second thing you should know—don’t assume the fish care at all how many miles you’ve put in to target them.

Thirdly, muskie are a challenging fish—to say the least—on gear, let alone fly. It is true what they say about fly fishing for them: it does give you a disadvantage. This is even truer if you’re an inexperienced fly angler such as myself.

Fourth thing, that disadvantage makes it SO worth the effort and heartache once you finally do get one to the net. And I can officially say, I know this to be true.

Fast forward three years from the time I made the utterly ridiculous decision to start to fly fishing just for the sake of my esox addiction—I’m in the Kawartha Lakes region, a short distance from my home base in central Ontario, with, surprise, surprise, my good friend, Aaron Jolicoeur.

angler holding ontario muskie
(Photo credit: Alyssa Lloyd)

We’re fishing a low-pressure lake with lots of fish, a lake Aaron has predicted many times would be the body of water where I land my first muskie.

Aaron fished gear for the better part of the day, but it wasn’t producing much either, so I decided to tough it out with my heavy fly to see if I could get at least a follow.

fly fisher casting
(Photo credit: Alyssa Lloyd)

Lo and behold, I got a hit way out from the boat, and I could tell this fish was big. It headed straight for the boat about 15 feet, then dove straight down into the weeds. This fish instinctively dove to the thick weed coverage, knowing full well whatever had a hold of it couldn’t follow it through there. 

angler releasing ontario muskie
(Photo credit: Alyssa Lloyd)

Not even thirty seconds later, my line goes slack. It’s gone. This is turning into Lac Seul all over again. Another fish flossed by my own hand. At this point, I believe I’m expected to just lose fish because I’m pretty good at that. 

“If I lose another fish today, throw me overboard,” was the statement I made to Aaron that morning. Certainly, glad it wasn’t followed through, but I would’ve deserved it. 

Each fish lost became easier to just move on from and keep fishing. Not even a swear word was mumbled. Well, maybe one.

We clip along at a charitable pace, feeling more like we are tournament fishing, my false casts become fewer, and I’m impressed at my own efficiency. Before too long, I had another snap at the fly, this time I went all out with a wild hook set, securing the furious hostile on the other end. Running parallel with the boat and then back towards the shore, I hand-strip it in realizing it’s much, much smaller than my last fish on.

Ask me if I cared. No matter how small this fish was, it was making it to the boat.

With just as much excitement as I, Aaron practically threw his rod down to leap for the net. A few exciting death rolls and jumps at the boat later, he was netted.

Three years of relief washed over me as I beamed at this tiny, tiny micro muskie with pure, unfiltered joy. Had it been 40 inches, I may have even shed a tear.

releasing ontario muskie
(Photo credit: Aaron Jolicoeur)

Finally, my stars had aligned, and my dumb idea three years ago came together. Now to aim for the 50-inch club.

About Alyssa Lloyd

Alyssa Lloyd is a photojournalist based out of Kenora working with Ontario's Sunset Country. The outdoors has been the center of her work and personal life for as long as she can remember. As an angler, Alyssa spends most of her time chasing multiple species on both conventional and fly gear. 

Recommended Articles

The Best Brook Trout Fishing

Discover world class fishing in Northern Ontario—home of the world record brook trout!

When to Use Bright Lures and Dark Lures

An interesting insight, using bright lures on bright days and dark lures on dark days.

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

How the Peaceful North Changed My Life

Daydreaming for a return all year long to the North.

A Whole Lota Lovin'

Burbot resembles nothing else that swims in our northern lakes and rivers.

Agich's Kaby Kabins

Fly-in for Amazing Black Bear Hunting and Fishing

French River Fever

This waterway is rich in lunge lore, having produced muskies in excess of 60 pounds.

Nipigon Brook Trout

Experience some high caliber trout fishing in Northwestern Ontario.

Catching Ontario Walleye

Pro Tips for Bait and Walley Presentations

Catching Bass Can Be Crystal Clear

Head to this Northwest Ontario resort for an opportunity to catch your personal best smallmouth bass.

Lakers of Lower Manitou: Fishing Just North of the U.S. Border

Fantastic Lake Trout Fishing at Manitou Weather Station.

Fishing and Foraging

Add some fresh foods and forage to your fishing adventures!

Don't Forget The Umbrella

It's raining smallmouth bass, walleye, and northern pike here in Northern Ontario

Big Water, Big Fish

Chinook fishing on the Nipigon River

Goulais River Muskie

Excellent fishing exists within a two-mile stretch near the mouth of Lake Superior.

Guided Fishing on Lake St. Clair

Captain Jim remembers over 600 muskies in a 3 month period.

Lake Nipigon Adventure

Fishing for Lake Trout, Walleye & Pike

Let the Sunshine In

Find the perfect time during hot summer weather for success on the water

Remote and Unique Lodges in Ontario

Ontario is home to drive-to, fly-in and boat-in experiences.

Fall Bass Class

Fall in the North can result in record size smallmouth and largemouth bass.