Beautiful Wild Brookies

Traditionally known for pike and walleye, Esnagami Lodge has incredible brook trout fishing.
tnff_esnagamilodge_wildbrooktrout.jpg

One of our favourite fly-in destinations in Northern Ontario is Esnagami Wilderness Lodge run by Eric and Sue Lund. Located a short 12-minute floatplane trip from Nakina, the lodge is nestled along the shoreline of the famous Esnagami Lake which is known for massive populations of walleye and northern pike. Of equal importance, this lodge has access to some incredible brook trout fishing on the rivers running into the lake.

esnagami lodge fleet of boats

The New Fly Fisher recently visited Esnagami Lodge to shoot a TV show. The goal was to experience both the northern pike and brook trout fishing on a fly. What an exceptional experience it turned out to be!

One of the important aspects of Esnagami Lodge is the fact that most guides, and even owner Eric Lund, are fanatical fly fishers. They understand what fly fishers need in terms of guiding, instruction, and even boat control. This greatly helps fly fishing guests, which is why so many anglers come back to the lodge year after year.

eric lund with brook trout

In the early season (May to early July), the big northern pike can be caught in shallow flats, bays, and adjacent to structure that holds walleye. Even as the summer warms up, the temperatures, the pike fishing stays excellent because Esnagami Lake is spring-fed, and water temperatures remain relatively cool. Guides know where springs are, which in turn attracts both walleye and northern pike. Weedbed growth is excellent throughout the lake by late June, and using topwater flies can result in some explosive takes! You will need to cast medium to large-sized flies for the pike, depending on when you visit the lodge. Colin found that either a 9- or 10-weight fast-action rod was ideal for punching out big flies. Pike designed fly lines with short, tapered heads are ideal for casting.

Watch Pike on a Fly

fly fisher casting

You will need a WF floating line, sink-tip line, and possibly a full-sink fly line for later in the summer to get your flies down. Colin likes to use a 4- to 6-foot leader of 50-pound test mono linked to 30-pound bite wire. RIO Products' bite wire is perfect for this type of fishing because you can vary the length of the leader, and it is easy to tie flies on. Effective patterns included: tarpon poppers, Dahlberg divers (large), and the infamous “Thunder Chicken” for topwater action. For streamers, our top choices are Murdich Minnows and Double-D’s.

murdich minnow flies

For those that love catching BIG wild brook trout on a fly, in the months of May to late June, Eric and his staff can guide you on some astonishing waters. The brook trout here vary in size from 2 to 6 pounds! Sometimes they can be caught on dry flies, but our most consistent means of triggering a strike is with weighted woolly buggers or white streamers. You don’t need sink-tip lines, just a WF floating line matched to a 9-foot leader. Your tippet should be at least a 3x size, as these fish will really slam your pattern. Usually, the brook trout are caught in fast water, top of pools, and near any structure adjacent to moving water. What we loved about our float trip down the river was the abundance of wildlife we saw, especially bald eagles! The best patterns are tan or purple woolly buggers (size 6 or 8), and white streamers such as zonkers or conehead bow river buggers. You will need 5- or 6-weight rods with fast action for making accurate casts and fighting the fish away from fallen trees and rocks. A trip down the Esnagami River for brook trout is something dreams are made of.

esnagami sunrise

Myself and the staff at The New Fly Fisher cannot recommend Esnagami Wilderness Lodge enough. Great fishing, accommodations, and outstanding service and staff.

Learn More

Website: www.esnagami.com/take-the-tour/fly-fishing
Phone: (519) 474-6988

(All photo credits: The New Fly Fisher)
About Colin McKeown

Colin McKeown is the producer of The New Fly Fisher Television Series, and several documentary series for the Outdoor Life Network, the Discovery Channel and the History Channel. With a passion of fly fishing, Colin's goal is to help both novice and veteran fly fishers everywhere by giving them a top-quality fly fishing series that will make them better anglers. Known for his keen sense of humour, Colin has two wonderful children and is married to the most understanding and patient woman in the world. 

Recommended Articles

Beyond the Walleye: Cracking the Code on Timiskaming’s Coffee-Coloured Giants

High-tech sonar and pink lures uncover a world-class smallmouth fishery.

Cracking the Code: How a Finesse Pivot Saved a Fly-In Dream at Buck Lake Lodge

When a massive mayfly hatch threatened to derail the mission, Pete turned to an unlikely bass-fishing staple to haul in trophy-class walleye.

World-Class Fishing and Wild Wonders of Timmins

Where trophy walleye are found within city limits and wilderness adventures include sleeping with the wolves.

The Right Tool for the Job

Check out this guide to gear up like a pro.

The Pipestone Foursome: Unlocking the Multi-Species Treasure Trove of Cedar Island Lodge

From explosive topwater smallmouth to rare northern largemouth and deep-dwelling lakers, the diversity of Northwest Ontario is put to the ultimate test.

Untouched Water And Total Freedom: The Flint Wilderness DIY Adventure

From trophy pike in expansive lakes to wild brook trout in hidden rivers, this Longlac destination is the ultimate base camp for the independent fly angler.

3 Essentials for Success at Pine Sunset Lodge

Make sure your tackle box and your gear bag are ready for the unpredictable weather and hard-fighting fish of Dinorwic Lake.

More Than Just a Tug on the Line

From the "lucky" rod to the silent drive home—why a trip to the North is actually a total system reset for the soul.

Eating Northern Pike

The Best Recipe to Cook This Fish

Nipigon Brook Trout

Experience some high caliber trout fishing in Northwestern Ontario.

Big Smallmouth on the Ned Rig

From cozy lakefront cabins to 4-pound bass, Snowshoe Camp Resort is the ultimate Algoma fishing getaway.

Catching Bucket List Walleyes at Dogtooth Lake Resort

The Ontario Experience visits Dogtooth Lake in Sunset Country

Accessible Paradise

Fish Noganosh Park for Monster Pike & Feisty Bass

Ice, Grit, And the Glory of the Kaby Lake Pike

The weather is a relentless challenge and the fish are the ultimate reward.

3 Surefire Strategies for Canadian Muskies

Fishing for Ontario Musky

3 Great Ontario Walleye Destinations

Karl of Extreme Angler recommends must do walleye lakes in Ontario.

Ten Mile Lake Lodge

Enjoy Northern hospitality fishing for splake, brook trout and lake trout

St. Francis Titans

Fishing the Original Muskie Capital of the World

True Colours

How important is your lure colour when selecting a bait?

Spring Fishing Tips For Any Angler

Increase your chance of fishing success