Master the Campfire Fish Fry

Simple Tricks To Get the Best Results

Anglers heading north to Ontario's Algoma Country have lots of reasons for wetting a line. Sport, fellowship, adventure and bragging rights are just some of the good reasons to plan a fishing trip in Algoma Country.

Just as important as catching fish, the always popular "fish fry" has motivated countless anglers to keep a few for the table.

The Grease

Not all cooking oils are ideal for frying fish. The best options are vegetable oils that have an exceptionally high flash point, or what some cooks call a "smoke point". The smoke point of cooking oil is the temperature at which the grease starts to vaporize and is in jeopardy of bursting into flames. This temperature varies from 360° to about 510° depending on the oil in question.

Safflower, peanut and corn oil are among the best options for frying fish because these oils all have a very high flash point. Oils to be avoided for frying include butter, margarine, olive oil and believe it or not lard or animal fat. The ideal frying temperature for fish is about 375° and the best way to maintain this temperature is with the help of a grease thermometer, available anywhere cooking supplies are sold.

Fish fried on location is always the best. The art of the “fish fry” starts with grease that has a high flashpoint. Good oils for frying fish include safflower, peanut and corn oil. (Photo credit: Mark Romanack)

Cast Iron

A cast-iron pot isn't the only way to fry fish, but it most certainly is one of the best options. Cast iron transfers heat better than other frying pan types, eliminating hot and cold spots in the grease. This goes double when frying over an open fire as a heat source.

Breading Options

The options for fish breading are almost endless and it seems everyone has their favourite commercially produced or homemade breading mix. Seasoned cracker crumbs, bread crumbs, wheat flour and cornflour are among the most common fish coatings. Bread, cracker and wheat flour yield a softer breading and cornflour yields a crunchy batter when fried.

Double Dry Breading

Some would argue that it's the breading that gives most fish flavour. It's true that popular species like walleye are so mild in flavour, that a little extra attention to how a breading is seasoned makes sense. Some even go so far as to bread the pieces of fish not once, but twice.

Double breading gives the pieces of fried fish a little extra flavour. To double bread, simply roll moist pieces of fish in a favourite dry breading and set the pieces on a cookie sheet. Set the breaded fish aside for a few minutes until the breading starts to get sticky then roll the pieces of fish a second time in the dry breading mix.

fresh walleye shorelunch fishing411
These walleye are on their way to a “shore lunch” held in their honour. There is no better way to honour the fish we covet than by keeping a few for the table. (Photo credit: Mark Romanack)

Beer Batter Breading

A "beer batter" breading also gives fried fish a more pronounced coating and flavour. One of the most popular options is to take a commercially produced dry coating mix like "Drakes" and mix it with a little beer to create a batter with about the same consistency as pancake batter. A standard package of Drake's breading mixes up perfectly with one 12-ounce can of beer. How perfect is that?

When using a beer batter breading it's important that the fish fillets be perfectly dry before they are dunked into the "beer batter". If the fillet is wet, the batter won't stick well to the fish.

Other Wet Batter Options

Beer batter is great, but there are other popular wet batter options for frying fish. A mixture of raw egg and milk whipped together makes an ideal dipping solution. Simply drop the pieces of fish into the egg and milk mixture and then roll the fish in a dry batter mix.

ontario shorelunch fishing411
Fresh from the lake to the frying pan, the Ontario shore lunch is more than worth the price of admission. (Photo credit: Mark Romanack)

Seasoning Options

No matter if your batter is wet, dry, homemade, or a commercially produced product, chances are the batter is going to need some help in the seasoning department. Some commercial batter mixes are already heavily seasoned so read the package and tread lightly here if the package indicates lots of seasonings are included. Homemade batter mixes are going to require a generous amount of salt, coarse ground pepper and lemon pepper to bring out the full flavour of the fish.

Is it Done Yet?

When the fillets hit the hot grease they should start bubbling aggressively. When the bubbling starts to ease and the fillets float to the top, the fish is cooked and ready to serve.

Extra Special Touches

A couple of ways to add an extra special touch to any fish fry is to drop a spoonful of butter into the grease when the fillets are almost completely cooked. The melting butter will impart a nice flavour to the fillets and brown them up perfectly.

Also, when the fillets are cooked, drain them over the grease for a couple of minutes and then dunk them back into the hot grease for about 30 seconds to a minute. This second dunking will help the fillets firm up and come out with a nice golden brown colour.

Summing It Up

Fried fish is always a treat but fish never tastes better than when it is freshly caught, cooked on location and eaten with friends and family. This season, take time to master the "fish fry" and share the wealth with those you care most about.

openfire shorelunch algoma fishing411
Shore lunch cooked over an open fire is an Algoma Country tradition. Fish never tastes better than when it is freshly caught, cleaned and cooked on location. (Photo credit: Mark Romanack)
About Mark Romanack

Mark Romanack is an outdoor writer, book author, fishing educator and the Host of the Fishing 411 television series broadcast on the World Fishing Network. For more information on fishing visit the Fishing 411 Facebook page or go to the Fishing 411 YouTube Channel to access a wealth of free educational fishing videos.

Recommended Articles

Family Fun at a Fishing Lodge

Family-friendly places to fish in Northern Ontario.

Group of Seven Touring Route

21 Panels, Mobile App to Experience the Landscape

Experience Crown land camping

5 Places to Crown land Camp in Algoma and 7 Ways to Do it Right

Winnie-the-Pooh's Ontario origins

Learn the History of World's Most Beloved Bear

Attractor Trolling for Lake Trout

Tips & Tricks You Need to Learn

Spinners are Winners

How to Use Spinners to Catch Brook Trout

Pike and Spoons

Fishing Techniques and Advice

Rigging Tips for Algoma Walleye

Best baits, best colours, and more!

A Trip into the Past

With the Mennonites of Algoma

Group of Seven Facts

10 Interesting Things You Didn't Know

Chapleau Game Preserve

Experience the World's Largest Game Preserve

Bringing Home Fish

Understanding Ontario Fishing Regulations

A Place to Stop

Batchawana Bay Tourist Centre is Now Open

Basic Late Fall Musky Techniques

A musky angler's approach to landing that big trophy.

Eye Opener

Best Bait, Lures and Scents to Catch Walleye

The Lost Harbour

Exploring Lake Superior's Coast

Gilbertson’s Maple Products

From Norwegian Roots to One of the Largest Maple Syrup Operations in Ontario

Brennan Harbour Resort

One for the Bucket List

Lifelong Love of Northern Pike

Explore the vast waters of Algoma Country and experience northern pike fishing!

Life Under The Dome

Glamping on the edge of Lake Superior at Rock Island Lodge