Creatures on the Fly: On the Hunt for Brook Trout

This fish was strong, hungry...and angry.

The night before I left I just couldn’t get comfortable. I was rolling, flipping and flicking through channels like it was a dull Friday night. My eyes were two big saucers that couldn’t get a grip on the screaming infomercial salesman and gadgets dancing on screen. I couldn’t escape the anticipation of an endless highway, tires ripping and rolling and gliding on cruise control through an endless landscape of emerald forests and untouched lakes.

I remember the feeling of waking up that morning—stomach in knots at who I would be meeting—those with transparent fins and spiny backs or the infamous "blue halo bellies" of the Northern brook trout. I slammed the door of my Jeep and cut out of my drive towards the Trans Canada (17). I was on a mission to meet the creatures of the North—a mission only completed once I had become one myself.

2 anglers casting in a stream

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

As I drove past signs of welcome, a couple of black bears and one yellow-eyed eagle, I turned off Trans Canada (17) in Thessalon, Ontario, and glided right into the parking lot of an inn just steps away from the off-ramp. Nestled beautifully into a crook of Lake Huron lies Carolyn Beach Inn, a stunning and expansive destination for anyone looking to relax, adventure, or enjoy homemade cuisine along the shores of a Great Lake. I was greeted by the family who owns the inn with warmth, kindness, and curiosity. Was I an angler on a mission? Yes. Was I desperate for authentic butter chicken for dinner? Oh, yes. At sunset, I sat on the picnic table overlooking the panoramic views of the lake and wondered how much of that delicious food I could possibly stuff in my gullet to keep me going for the next day. Turns out it was quite a lot. I slept.

The sun had barely crested the misted canopy when I spotted our guide, Adam Vallee of Angling Algoma leaning against his truck with enough coffee to last us several days, let alone just one. As long as I was twitching that rod tip, I was happy to get the caffeine shakes. I thought a nice Cray pattern would be that perfect pairing: twitch, stop. Twitch, stop. Coffee sip, sip, twitch, stop. Laughing at our hilarity, Adam and I geared up into our waders and entered the river that would flicker glimpses of blue halos and white-tipped fins—they were there, and so were we.

Armed with a 6wt and intermediate sinking line, Adam and I maneuvered around slick boulders and rushing rapids. There was a deep cut through a sandy bottom in the middle of the river, and as all great guides do, Adam had stalked the rivers the day before in order to find where the brook trout lie.

angler fishing smallmouth bass

Ontario's Algoma Country is home to a variety of species including walleye, northern pike, brook trout, and smallmouth bass. (Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

They are hunters, movers, and chasers - they seek the food and the currents to fatten up for spawning season, and we wanted to meet them halfway. He knew that the magnitude of the ugly pressured weather fronts moving in would crush these fish to the bottom of the pool, so it was imperative we lead with heavy flies and a slower retrieve. It only took about 3 casts for me to feel a hit, and when I finally set the hook I shouted for Adam and nearly exploded with frustration when I pulled out a stick the size of my arm. He laughed, and I doubled hauled.

“Take a step down Alyx, and put it right on the seam where the trench begins. That’s where they are”.

Eyeing Adam, I did as he said and layout a cast that may have been the ugliest of all time. The one where you pick it up again and hope no one saw, type of cast.

“LEAVE IT,” he said.

Feeling that urge to toss up the line and cast it again, I fought like the dickens to do as he said. Two twitches, a breath, and a raise of the rod tip (to begin another cast) were when I was struck - a strike so complete that the feeling emulated the final ‘clunk’ of a hole-in-one.

“THERE!” Loud, with a strip and trout set.

When a creature that you wait for, cast to, and cannot see finally hits your fly, the moment becomes surreal. For some reason, you become nimble, able to dance around the rocks and structure, moving backwards and forwards to complete the meet—two of you waiting to see what is on the other end. This fish was strong, hungry, and angry. The blackened face of a brook trout is almost frightening until you gaze into those blue halos surrounding the red specks of its silken body. When Adam tossed the net and cradled the trout, it was then that dropped my rod and slowly edged towards it.

ontario brook trout

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

The water was 46 degrees Celsius, and I had my arms deep into that net. Making sure it never left the water, I lifted and tilted the back of this fish to reveal itself. It was then that I did the same, in the form of total and complete surrender. This is why people spend hours and hours waiting for a grand 3 seconds of ‘...wow’.

“Adam, this is my personal best brook trout,” was all I needed to say.

A careful release and I felt myself go, too. Into the cold waters of the North, following that creature around like it was the last thing I would ever do, ever wanted and ever needed.

A huge thank you to the Carolyn Beach Inn and guide Adam Vallee for an exceptional experience in Algoma Country, Ontario.

About Alyx Parks

Motivated by restless waters and migrating fish, Alyx has been adventuring through Ontario’s river systems for over 20 years and has dedicated her spare time to helping people find that same joy. She believes that everyone can adventure together, and is focused on getting people out of the office and into nature through fly fishing. Alyx is a motivational speaker and professional Career Coach in the Tech industry as well as an aspiring photographer and dog-mom to a (relentlessly) bouncy Aussie Shepherd. You can find her building coaching programs, hosting Women in Fly Fishing events and (most often) tripping and falling over rocks.

Recommended Articles

Predicting Lake Thickness

When Will Ontario Lakes Freeze Over This Winter?

Top 8 Places to Ice Fish in Ontario

Ice fishing in Ontario offers diverse catches in serene winter settings.

5 Deadliest Fishing Lures

Use these lures when ice fishing for lake trout in Northern Ontario.

Rainy Lake Walleye

Fishing at La Belle’s Birch Point Camp

Don’t Be Afraid Of Muskies

Muskies are fish of 10,000 casts and are found in large bodies of water in Northwestern Ontario.

Pleasant Cove Resort

Setting sights on Georgian Bay Northern Pike

Top 5 Baits for Smallmouth and Largemouth Bass

What baits do you use to target bass? Find out why these 5 are the best!

Lake Nipigon Adventure

Fishing for Lake Trout, Walleye & Pike

Summer Brook Trout

Expert Advice for Fishing Ontario Lakes

Balsam Lake Walleye

How to Use Snap Jigging to Catch Walleye

Top 5 Flies for Smallmouth Bass

The inside scoop on bass flies from the hosts of The New Fly Fisher.

Salmon Fishing

The Michipicoten River is a Sleeper for Chinook

Sweeping the Basin

October is a Great Time to Fish for Ontario Crappie

Go Shallow For More Walleye

Walleye anglers think the fish are always in at least ten-foot or deeper. They're wrong!

High Water on the Woods

When fishing in high water, there are a few ways to navigate them and land your trophy muskie.

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

10 Facts About Lake of the Woods

10 facts amazing about this massive Northwest Ontario Lake!

Ten Mile Lake Lodge

Enjoy Northern hospitality fishing for splake, brook trout and lake trout

Adventure Walleye Fishing Lake Nipigon Style

Fishing 411 Television visits Pasha Lake Cabins

A Whole Lota Lovin'

Burbot resembles nothing else that swims in our northern lakes and rivers.