Fly Rod vs. Freshwater Monsters: A Musky Quest at Cedar Lake Lodge

Chasing the "fish of ten thousand casts" with a fly rod in the heart of Ontario's Sunset Country.
Cedar Lake Lodge

When The New Fly Fisher asked me to pack my gear for a musky shoot at Cedar Lake Lodge in Northern Ontario’s Sunset Country, I didn’t know whether to be excited or nervous. Muskies are powerful, elusive, and downright mythical, especially on a fly rod. But I’ve always said, if it swims, it can be caught on a fly, so I accepted the challenge.

cedar lake lodge welcome sign
Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher

Cedar Lake Lodge: A World-Class Musky Fishing Destination in Northwest Ontario

The drive north along Highway 17 through Sault Ste. Marie in Sunset Country is nothing short of stunning. After a quick fuel stop in Dryden, I rolled down a paved road to the Cedar Lake launch, where lodge owner Wade loaded my gear onto his pontoon. Ten minutes later, Cedar Lake Lodge appeared, cozy cabins, a massive dock loaded with fishing boats, and wilderness in every direction. It didn’t take long to see that this place runs like a well-oiled machine, and musky is their specialty.

fly gear
Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher

My guide, Nolan, was a true musky fanatic. He knew exactly where these predators held — tight to structure and ready to ambush,  and he put us on fish right away. Talking with other guests, it was clear that many anglers go self-guided and still do extremely well. Some throw flies, others use baitcasters, but everyone comes for the same reason: world-class musky. The lodge record sits just shy of 54 inches, with countless fish in the mid- to high-40s caught and seen every season.

musky
Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher

Fly Fishing for Musky: Gear, Technique, and Big Flies

On day one, we eased into a rocky, timber-filled bay, classic musky water. I started with a 9-weight setup, but after a few heavy casts, I knew it wasn’t enough rod for the flies or the fish. Switching to an 8.5-foot 11-weight made all the difference. The rod loaded effortlessly and had the backbone needed for these giants.

Over four days, we moved eighteen muskies, far beyond my goal of three. Six followed close enough to work them in a figure-eight beside the boat, and four ate farther out, though none stayed pinned. That’s musky fishing. Every follow felt like a win.

Cedar Lake Lodge impressed me from start to finish. Clean cabins, great boats, knowledgeable owners, and a fishery that truly earns the “world-class” label. And if musky isn’t your game, the lake is packed with big smallmouth bass, walleye, and crappie.

smallmouth bass
Cedar Lake Lodge offers trophy fishing for musky, northern pike, walleye and smallmouth bass. Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher

Plan Your Musky Fishing Trip to Cedar Lake Lodge

If you’re after a real northern escape, remote island cabins, unforgettable scenery, and the chance to chase freshwater’s ultimate predator, Cedar Lake Lodge in Ontario’s Sunset Country is the place. Wild, peaceful, and unforgettable.

Recommended Articles

Winter Fish Scents

How to Use Fish Scents When Ice Fishing

The Muskie: A Lean Mean Fighting Machine

Ontario is the number one Muskie destination on the planet.

Top 5 Musky Destinations in Ontario

The Musky Hunter shows you where to land the best musky in Ontario waters.

Fall Walleye

Using Chub, Bottom Bouncers and Beads

Drive-to Ontario Lodges

Ontario has the perfect easy-to-access fishing oasis for every angler!

Worm Your Way In

Try this go-to bait for bass on your next Northern Ontario angling adventure

Top 5 Tips To Fish Smallmouth Bass in Ontario

Ontario has some of the top smallmouth bass opportunities. in the world.

Veteran Grit vs. High-Tech Odds: The Ultimate Algoma Derby Showdown

Facing off against a powered-up duo and a technological disadvantage in a length-based battle across the pristine waters of Whitefish and Manitouwik Lakes.

Go Shallow For More Walleye

Walleye anglers think the fish are always in at least ten-foot or deeper. They're wrong!

Double Trouble for Fall Crappies

Check out this expert trick

Fall Bass Class

Fall in the North can result in record size smallmouth and largemouth bass.

Pike Aplenty

How to select the right spot to catch pike in late fall fishing in Ontario.

Sunset Country Outfitters

Some of the best multi-species action in Ontario’s Sunset Country

Float Fishing

The Fast Track to Superior Steelhead

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

Best of The Musky West

Have you fished these top 3 musky lakes in Northwestern Ontario?

Wilderness WAlleye

Fishing Jumbo Perch, Walleye and Pike at Kanipahow Resort

20 Years With Fish TV!

Fish TV discusses their favourite Ontario catches

Streamers for Big Pike

Northern Pike are the apex predator in many of Ontario’s waters.

Salmon Of The Soo

Fishing for Atlantic Salmon on the St. Marys River.