Cook the Classic Shore Lunch

You could go to the fanciest restaurant in the world, and it wouldn’t taste any better than this.
87b6bf8d94ff18f53aa0d3f3cff62953_XL.jpg

What—you've never had the pleasure of a Northern Ontario shore lunch? Shame on you! It is the highlight of every fishing trip I've ever enjoyed when we've pulled the boat up onto the shoreline of scenic spruce or pine-covered island and cooked our freshly caught fish over a crackling wood fire.

boats on shoreline
You have no idea of how delicious fresh fish can be until you've pulled the boat up onto the shore of scenic spruce or pine-covered island and cooked your catch over a crackling wood fire. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

Trust me—you have no idea how delicious fresh fish can be until you've cooked it minutes after you've caught it.

And the cool thing is, a shore lunch is so easy to prepare.

I would hate to tell you how many shore lunches I've prepared for family, friends and guests over the years, but it is many hundreds, if not thousands.

And here is the recipe that most folks have said is their all-time favourite:

  • flour seasoned with salt and pepper 
  • Egg Beater or a couple of beaten eggs
  • Corn Flake crumbs
  • Italian Flavoured Bread Crumbs (with Romano cheese, herbs and spices)
  • Canola oil
  • fresh lemons
  • salt and pepper

I like to arrange four loaf pans side-by-side with the fish fillets in one, the seasoned flour in another, the Egg Beater in the third and equal amounts of cornflake crumbs and Italian-flavoured bread crumbs in the fourth.

That is also the order in which you prepare the fillets.

Simply take a piece of fish, drop it into the pan of seasoned flour and give it a good shake. Then give it a bath in the egg wash before finally dipping and shaking it in the pan of crumbs.

While I am preparing the fillets, I like to start the fire so that by the time I am finished, it is hot and ready for the frying pan, which brings us to a real secret to preparing great crispy shore lunch fish. Always heat up the oil so that it is hot before you put in the fish.

fresh walleye fillets
The fire is crackling, the oil is hot and Sandro Fragale is all set to cook some fresh walleye that he and his buddies caught while fishing in Northwestern Ontario’s Sunset Country. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

The old-timers will tell you that you know when the oil is ready because "when you spit in the pan, the pan will spit back at you." It is a great tip, too, but unless you're cooking just for yourself, I suggest you take a bit of the crumb dressing and drop it in the oil instead. When the oil swirls and bubbles around it immediately, it is ready.

Then gently slide in the fillets. They'll be golden brown in only two or three minutes, so watch them carefully and when they look finger-licking-good, flip them over and fry the other side.

When the oil is at the proper temperature, the entire cooking process will take only a couple of minutes, after which you can slide the crispy, crunchy fillets onto a plate covered with paper towels to drain off any excess oil.

I like to grind sea salt and pepper over the fillets and squeeze the juice from a fresh lemon or two over them while they're steaming hot too.

Then, it is a simple matter of everyone digging in and enjoying the finest fresh fish you could ever imagine.

campfire fish fry
Fish never tastes finer than when you prepare them simply and cook them quickly in hot oil over a crackling wood fire in Northern Ontario. Time to grab a plate and dig in. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

Of course, you can prepare your walleye, perch, crappies or pike this way, too, when you get home but for a real change of pace, especially if you want to impress your family or friends try my baked Mediterranean Walleye.

A couple of years ago, I was invited to participate in the Generation Next Angler Celebrity Cook-off at the Mid-Canada Boat Show in Winnipeg.

Twice each day, during the four days of the show, various folks went nose-to-nose cooking up their favourite walleye recipes for a panel of judges.

Each cook-off lasted an hour, and I can tell you that once everyone was seated, not a single person left the room.

At the end of the four days of competition, the results were tabulated, and in the end, I won—or rather, the walleye won—with this delicious, heart-healthy, and easy-to-prepare recipe.

Gord's Mediterranean Walleye Supreme

  • 1.5 lb fresh boneless, skinless walleye fillets
  • a handful of green olives stuffed with garlic & cut into small pieces
  • a handful of black olives cut into small pieces
  • a handful of sundried tomatoes packed in olive oil, cut into small pieces
  • a handful of crumbled feta cheese
  • fresh tomato slices
  • fresh lemon
  • white wine (optional)
  • salt and pepper

Directions

Wash and thoroughly dry the walleye fillets between paper towels before laying them on the bottom of a casserole or glass baking dish. Salt and pepper the fish to taste. Add a splash of white wine. Sprinkle the green olives, black olives and sundried tomato over the fish. Sprinkle on the feta cheese. Finally, cover everything with a layer of fresh tomato slices. Pop it into a preheated 400°F oven and cook for approximately 20 minutes. When it is time to serve, squeeze the juice from half of the fresh lemon over the steaming fish.

It's a meal fit for a king or queen and the most fitting way I know to celebrate the finest fish that Northern Ontario has to offer.

About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Ice, Grit, And the Glory of the Kaby Lake Pike

The weather is a relentless challenge and the fish are the ultimate reward.

3 Essentials for Success at Pine Sunset Lodge

Make sure your tackle box and your gear bag are ready for the unpredictable weather and hard-fighting fish of Dinorwic Lake.

Cracking the Code: How a Finesse Pivot Saved a Fly-In Dream at Buck Lake Lodge

When a massive mayfly hatch threatened to derail the mission, Pete turned to an unlikely bass-fishing staple to haul in trophy-class walleye.

Cast Into the Heart of a Walleye Paradise

Experience world-class angling and remote island luxury at the only resort on the pristine waters of Route Lake.

The Right Tool for the Job

Check out this guide to gear up like a pro.

Welcome to Wally World

Lake Nipissing is a must-fish destination, putting you right in the heart of the action for post-spawn walleye, pike, and big bass.

More Than Just a Tug on the Line

From the "lucky" rod to the silent drive home—why a trip to the North is actually a total system reset for the soul.

Heavy Rods and Heart-Stopping Follows: Fly Fishing for Muskies

An ultimate destination for fly anglers looking to test their gear and grit against the North’s most legendary predator.

Why Anglers Are Falling for Golden Lake in Ontario’s Ottawa Valley

From trophy bass to beachside cottages, Golden Lake blends serious fishing with relaxed cottage life.

Gear Up for the Fish of Ten Thousand Casts

Preparation is the only thing standing between you and the trophy musky of a lifetime at Cedar Lake Lodge.

Why Georgian Bay is a Fly Angler’s Final Frontier

Discover how a 75-year-old fishing camp serves as the ultimate basecamp for navigating the transition from river currents to island shoals.

Non-Stop Action and Trophy Catches at Timberlane Lodge

With 3,000 miles of shoreline and world-renowned natural reproduction, this 150-mile-long fishery is a must-visit for every serious angler.

Untouched Water And Total Freedom: The Flint Wilderness DIY Adventure

From trophy pike in expansive lakes to wild brook trout in hidden rivers, this Longlac destination is the ultimate base camp for the independent fly angler.

The Eagle has Landed

If you're looking to make your Ontario fishing dreams come true, this is the place to do it.

Smallmouth & Largemouth at Chaudière Lodge

A nostalgic fishing trip on the French River & Lake Nipissing.

10 Facts About Lake of the Woods

10 facts amazing about this massive Northwest Ontario Lake!

The Pipestone Foursome: Unlocking the Multi-Species Treasure Trove of Cedar Island Lodge

From explosive topwater smallmouth to rare northern largemouth and deep-dwelling lakers, the diversity of Northwest Ontario is put to the ultimate test.

Fishing and Foraging

Add some fresh foods and forage to your fishing adventures!

Ontario Carp Championship

Is Ontario the Carp fishing capital of the world?

Top 5 Flies for Smallmouth Bass

The inside scoop on bass flies from the hosts of The New Fly Fisher.