Hurry Sundown

Why Ice Fishing at Sunset Gets the Perch Chowing Down
gpyzer_sundown_trout1.jpg

“The best days you have fishing are the ones that surprise even yourself, don’t you think, Grandpa?"

I looked over at my grandson, Liam, who was perched in the passenger seat beside me drinking a hot chocolate as we drove home. Along the lonely, dark, snowy, backcountry road, I spotted a smile sneak across his face.

He was right, though—they are the days in your dreams.

And we’d just come off a scorching streak of hot winter bites for everything from plate-shaped black crappies to giant lake trout and trophy-size splake to braggin’-size jumbo perch.

ice angler holding lake trout

What was even more interesting, though, was the fact that we had caught the fish in such a dissimilar variety of Northwestern Ontario lake types. It seems nothing was consistent or patternable—except for one critical detail.

We caught all of the fish, every superb specimen, in different weather conditions, within the same one-hour period every day. The fish all hit between 4:30 pm and 5:30 pm, just as the sun was setting.

ice angler holding northern pike

Sunset is the prime time to target northern pike and lake trout.

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again, but give me the first hour of daylight in the morning and the last hour in the afternoon, and you can have the rest of the day.

In a strange way, sunrise and sunset are like the surface of the water, which good friend and legendary muskie guru, Dick Pearson calls the “zone of chaos”— so much fish activity seems to be crammed into that marvellous couple of inches of air and water.

The same accounts for the first and last hours of light each day. It's when Nature comes alive and goes to sleep. And if you love to ice fish in Northern Ontario as much as I do, it is when you can't afford to catch yourself napping.

ice angler holding lake trout

Indeed, sight-feeding fish like yellow perch are positively phototactic. Like humans, they can see much better during the day than they can at night. So when a new day dawns, it's like a rooster crowing. The changing light levels wake up the fish from their slumber positions near the bottom, and they start feeding lustfully.

In fact, in transparent lakes like Southern Ontario’s renowned Lake Simcoe, where round gobies blanket the bottom, the first light ice bite has become legendary. Sleep in and you'll miss it because many days you’ll be fishing for jumbo perch that you can clearly see milling below your hole in the crystal clear water, staring at your bait or lure, but refusing to bite it. They are so stuffed, having eaten so much at first light, that they’re looking now for a dinner mint at best.

young ice angler holding perch
Yellow perch typically don't see well in dim-light conditions, so they feed actively at first and last light.

Here is something else I think you’ll find interesting. Walleye, which just so happen to be the yellow perch's Darth Vader arch enemy, are negatively phototactic. They hate the bright lights of Broadway or any other venue. So, during the day, perch enjoy the advantage of prey over predator.

Eventually, however, all good things come to an end, so when sunset arrives along with its quickly diminishing levels of light, it's the signal for the perch to chow down one last time before hitting the sack…or, in their case, the relative safety and security of the bottom of the lake.

ice angler holding walleye
Walleye are negatively phototactic, which means they see better in the dark than in the daylight.

Unfortunately for the tasty yellow perch, however, these same conditions are a signal to walleyes—as well as lake trout, splake, northern pike, and several other species—that their dinner is out and about feeding, but quickly losing its ability to see them.

The tables are turning, in favour of the big-eyed toothy marauders. And of all the predators out at this time of the evening, the savvy ice angler often reigns supreme.

ice angler with lake trout
As Gord's grandson, Liam Whetter will tell you, you can surprise even yourself when you fish as the sun is setting.

So, if you would like to surprise yourself the next time you go ice fishing in Northern Ontario, remember...hurry sundown.

(All photo credits: Gord Pyzer)
About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Ontario’s Array of Fishing Opportunities

From drive-to, fly-in, and train-in lodges, to outpost camps in Ontario, here's everything you need to know.

Yellow Perch Egg-Stacy

Hardcore perch anglers, read on!

Paradise Cove Resorts

On the hunt for Musky in Ontario's Sunset Country

The Eagle has Landed

If you're looking to make your Ontario fishing dreams come true, this is the place to do it.

Glide to Success

The province of Ontario has more muskie waters than anywhere else on Earth!

Wabigoon Walleye Extreme

Trophy-sized Walleye in the 30" Class

5 Reasons To Go Fishing In The Fall

Tips for catching Ontario trophies.

Horwood Lake Lodge

Summertime Bass and Walleye from Horwood Lake in Northeastern Ontario

The Tigers of Sunset Country

The most picturesque of all freshwater fish.

5 Ontario Fish Species to Target on Fly

As technology has improved fly anglers have the ability to target multi-species on fly.

Cash in on Early Season Walleyes

Opening day of the walleye season in Ontario is one of the most-anticpiated dates for anglers..

Bass Fishing at Agnew Lake Lodge

This family-owned lodge is the perfect base for excellent angling adventures in Northeastern Ontario.

10 Steps for Winterizing Your Boat

Essential Steps for Winterizing and Preparing Your Boat for Storage

Fly Casting In The Wind

Use these tips to help make it easier to when out fly fishing in Ontario.

Shallow Water Fishing in Sunset Country

Fish are still in shallow water—and up here in Northwestern Ontario, they’re more than willing to bite.

Forget Skinny Smallmouth

Chiblow Lake Lodge offers an all-inclusive experience on a smallmouth factory famous for 5-pound-plus bass.

World Class Muskie at Young's Wilderness Camp

Lake of The Woods for Muskie and Walleye

Bob Izumi searches for bass and pike

Fishing unfamiliar territory, Bob Izumi lands monster smallies and Northern pike

Topwater Bass

Targeting Spring Bass at Dog Lake Resort

Guardian Eagle Resort

Travel in style to this remote wilderness lodge in Northwestern Ontario for excellent fishing.