Size Matters

While we often need to downsize our baits and go finesse, there are plenty of other times when we need to do the very opposite thing.
leadin.jpg

Living in Northern Ontario and getting to fish and hunt at least five out of every seven days suggests that I live a pretty charmed life. All those hours spent on the water also mean that I can do things -- "play," I like to call it - that most folks with limited time wouldn't dare try.

Like sitting over top a school of husky crappies and seeing just how important the size of your bait is when it comes to attracting and triggering the fish to bite. It is the game I played yesterday when I launched my 16-foot deep-V Alumacraft boat, equipped with a 20 hp Mercury tiller four-stroke and transom-mounted MinnKota electric trolling motor that I keep for all my backcountry travel adventures. It gets me into the remote small and medium-sized lakes - my Northern Ontario laboratory - that many anglers tend to ignore.

It is a big mistake.

In fact, yesterday, I didn't motor more than a mile down the flat, mirror-calm lake when I looked at my sonar screen and watched it light up with big red arcs hovering a foot or so off the bottom. And when I dropped a 3/16th ounce chartreuse jig with a brown chenille body and blue hackle tail over the side of the boat, I felt a distinct thump, set the hook and reeled up a plump 13-inch black crappie.

Now, normally catching a fish on your first cast is bad luck - especially a 13-incher - but there were so many more crappies waving on the sonar screen that I knew it wasn't going to be the case this day. So I donned my lab coat - okay, it was a warm wool sweater -- and began the research.

Science has shown us that crappies, which have large mouths for their bulk, have an optimal forage size of 2 1/2 inches. We also know that in the fall, the fish are feeding uncompromisingly as they pack on the calories to get themselves through the upcoming cold winter months.

So, after I caught three or four more gorgeous 12- to 14-inch fish, I did what any inquisitive angler would do. I put down the big jig rod that was working so well and picked up an outfit on which I had tied a similar but much smaller jig.

The results were outrageous.

Believe it or not, I struggled to get a bite. Okay, well, struggled may not be entirely accurate, but at the very least, the fish were noticeably less excited about the appetizer than they were with the roast beef dinner.

And get this. The first fish that I hooked was only eight, maybe nine inches long. Ditto, the second and third. It was as though the school of husky crappies had packed up and moved on while a herd of diminutive "silver dollars" took their place.

But it wasn't the case.

As soon as I had put down the small jig rod and picked up the bigger outfit, I reconnected on the very first drop over the side of the boat. I felt a bang and hauled another slab crappie into the boat.

Even more surprising, however, was the location of the jig. It was so far down the big fish's throat that I wondered how it didn't choke on it.

And so it went for the rest of the day.

Amazingly, I could call the shot simply by the size of the jig that I selected.

If I wanted to catch a bigger crappie, I chose the larger 3/16th-ounce lead head. If I wanted a smaller crappie, I lowered the 1/16th model. Even more revealing, the few nicer-sized fish that I caught while presenting the smaller jig were barely hooked on the lip, whereas the steady stream of plate-size beauties was gagging on the big jig that was so far down their throats.

The takeaway from yesterday's experimentation is obvious and something I've preached for some time. While we often need to downsize our baits and go finesse, there are plenty of other times when we need to do the very opposite thing.

ontario crappie
Any time you find the mother lode -- check the sonar screen in this image - it is time to offer the fish a variety of lure sizes. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

And if we did it more often, for black crappies, walleyes, yellow perch, bass, northern pike, lake trout and muskies, we'd catch more and bigger fish.

Which is why size matters when you fish in Northern Ontario.

About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Twitchbait Smallies

Your guide to open water smallmouth fishing in Atikokan.

Top 5 Baits for Smallmouth and Largemouth Bass

What baits do you use to target bass? Find out why these 5 are the best!

3 Great Ontario Walleye Destinations

Karl of Extreme Angler recommends must do walleye lakes in Ontario.

5 Places to Shore Fish

Fish’n Canada shows you where to go shore fishing in Ontario.

10 Facts About Lake of the Woods

10 facts amazing about this massive Northwest Ontario Lake!

Summer Brook Trout

Expert Advice for Fishing Ontario Lakes

Speckle Splake Spectacular

Ice Fishing for big Northern Ontario speckled & splake trout.

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

Summer Smallmouth

Bass Techniques to Help You Catch a Trophy

Long Nose Gar

A Fish for the Bucket List

Eating Northern Pike

The Best Recipe to Cook This Fish

Don’t Be Afraid Of Muskies

Muskies are fish of 10,000 casts and are found in large bodies of water in Northwestern Ontario.

The Tigers of Sunset Country

The most picturesque of all freshwater fish.

5 Canoe & Kayak Fishing Destinations

Where to go canoe and kayak fishing in Ontario.

Top 5 Tips To Fish Smallmouth Bass in Ontario

Ontario has some of the top smallmouth bass opportunities. in the world.

Ontario Fly Fishing Hotspots

The Top 10 List from The New Fly Fisher TV Show.

Experiencing Prince Edward County - The Angler’s Way

Walleye fishing on the world-famous Bay of Quinte.

Wasi Lake Fishing

Fishing at Booth Landing Camping & Cottages

Multi-Species Action

With so many lakes in Ontario, it's hard to narrow down the best multi-species lakes. We're here to help!

Reaching Deep For Walleye

Fishing for big Walleye in Ontario's Bay of Quinte.