Sweeping the Basin For Crappies

Without question, October is Gord's favourite time of year to catch crappie

Oh, my, you have to love autumn in Northern Ontario because there is a never-ending list of exciting things to do in such splendid surroundings.

In just the last four days, for example, I've gone grouse hunting with my grandson, spent time with him in the bear blind, set up some new deer stands, gone puddle jump shooting for ducks and geese, caught smallmouth bass and walleyes, and swept the basin clean for crappies.

I get tired just thinking about it all, but it highlights the fact that when fall rolls around, there aren't enough hours in a typical Northern Ontario day.

And I wouldn't have it any other way.

Speaking about crappies, they are one of my much-loved fish and the month of October is without question my favourite time of the year to catch them.

I got onto an amazing pattern the other day, something I've been refining for several years now, and it was out-of-this-world good. So spectacular, in fact, that had we been fishing together I wouldn't have let you pinch me, because if this was a dream, I didn't want to wake up.

I call it sweeping the basin and I guarantee the tactic will work for you wherever you fish for plate-size slabs in the northern part of the province.

What I did after launching the boat on one of my favourite Sunset Country lakes was to slowly motor around while I monitored my sonar unit and looked for fish. A big mistake many anglers make is arriving at the lake or river so excited at the prospect of fishing that they drop down their lines before they've found anything to catch. Resist the urge to it and spend more time early in the day searching for fish.

gord pyzer holding ontario black crappie

As Gord Pyzer explains, when you use your trolling motor to sweep the basin, the results can be impressive. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

Once I found them, as I suspected and is usually the case in the early to mid-autumn period, the crappies were spread out along the bottom, hanging a foot or two above it, loosely bunched up. In a couple of more weeks, they will drop down closer to the basin and congregate in much denser schools, but right now, they are still strung out in loosey-goosey pods.

So, parking your boat over top of the fish and presenting a vertical bait or lure to them is much less productive than trolling.

But there was a catch, or a detail, that mattered immensely. While the crappies definitely wanted my bait to be swimming, they didn't want it to be moving quickly. In fact, they were so particular about only hitting it at the proper speed that I was reminded of Muhammad Ali when he was asked how he was going to beat Sonny Liston. The champ replied that he was going to...float like a butterfly, and sting like a bee!

Thank you, Mohammad, because that is exactly how the crappies wanted me to present the jig!

angler with 2 black crappie fish

Gord Pyzer says the secret to catching huge black crappies in the fall is to float like a butterfly, sting like a bee. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

I should mention, too, that I was using a short-shanked 1/16th-ounce blue and white Reel Bait Flasher jig with a tiny willowleaf blade beneath the head and a 3-inch soft plastic minnow pinned to the hook.

If I dropped the combination straight down over the side of the boat, in front of a crappies' nose, I couldn't get the fish to bump it. But if I floated it like a butterfly, I'd sting it like a bee.

ontario black crappie

When the black crappies start suspending near the bottom it is time to use a 1/16th-ounce Reel Bait Flasher jig and 3-inch soft plastic minnow to sweep them up. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

What I did, in fact, every time I spotted a strung-out school of crappies was to pop my 20 HP Mercury outboard into reverse and backtroll at the slowest possible speed. Then, as soon as I noticed on the sonar screen that I was moving at .8 miles an hour, I'd pop the motor into neutral and let the boat come to a complete stop.

Visualizing what was happening, I am certain that as I slowly backtrolled into the wind, my jig was pulled up off the bottom, well above the fish. But, then, when I popped the motor into neutral, with the lure at its apex, it floated like a butterfly back down to the bottom. And that is when every single crappie ate the bait.

gord pyzer ontario black crappie fishing

When you find crappies strung out in loose pods, Gord Pyzer says it is more productive to troll for them rather than sit over top and make a vertical presentation. (Photo credit: Gord Pyzer)

In fact, if it wasn't floating precisely this way -- think how you'd sweep the kitchen floor with a broom -- the crappies wouldn't touch it. But as soon as I slowly pulled it away from them, they'd watch it drift up. And then, when I stopped the boat and allowed the jig to float back down, in an arc, like a butterfly, it was lights out, game on, hand-to-hand combat.

Lord, I wish there were more than 24 hours on a typical Northern Ontario autumn day.

About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Difficult Day Walleye

Learn a few techniques to address the sometimes challenging fishing conditions for walleye.

Summertime Walleye

Fish for Walleye, Muskie or Smallmouth on the Indian Lake Chain.

Trophy Fishing in Northern Ontario

Northern Ontario offers anglers a variety of choices of species and fishing options.

Flying in for Ontario Northern Pike

Kaby Lake is a phenomenal lake for both Walleye and Northern Pike fishing.

In Search of Brookies

Fly Fishing at Esnagami Wilderness Lodge

3 Secret Tips for Landing Ontario Muskies

Muskies aren’t easy to catch. So here’s a simple formula to change that.

Top 5 Flies for Smallmouth Bass

The inside scoop on bass flies from the hosts of The New Fly Fisher.

Creatures on the Fly: On the Hunt for Brook Trout

Angling in Algoma Country means a chance to reel in some of the best brook trout in the world.

Bear Creek Cottages

Multi-Species Fishing on Lake Nipissing

Beaded Lures

Find out why these chintzy plastic beads are the perfect lure.

The Inside Scoop

The fall is the perfect time to hit the water when the fish are starting to feed.

Whopper Walleye

Discover the 3 lodges in Ontario’s Sunset Country that offer trophy walleye in big waters.

Northern Pike Aplenty

Why the pike are so active near the end of the ice fishing season.

Off-Grid Ontario Fishing Adventures

Escape to one of these 4 remote Ontario outposts this summer

Drive-to Ontario Lodges

Ontario has the perfect easy-to-access fishing oasis for every angler!

Dream Fishing Trips

These two Ontario lodges, just across the border from Minnesota, offer anglers the chance to fish multiple species.

Different Strokes

From jigging and buzzing to chunking' and windin', there's no right or wrong way to work a fishing lure.

Kesagami Wilderness Lodge

Kesagami Lake has just under a million acres of fishable water that is chock full of pike and walleye.

First Time Walleye Fishing for Beginners in Ontario

I was lucky to share that experience with first-time anglers twice last week. 

Pike and Walleye: Ontario’s One-Two Punch

Walleye and the northern pike reside in the same bodies of water. When one's not biting, the other might!