Top Flies for Northern Pike

Fishing Tips From the hosts of The New Fly Fisher

There is little arguing that the northern pike is the most dominant fish to swim in the freshwater systems of Northern Ontario. They are relentless hunters which will often lay in wait for their prey to casually swim by and be devoured. They are meat-eaters and often will take fish that are extremely large offerings. When we target northern pike in the fly fishing world, we do our best to imitate these big offerings by throwing big flies for big pike. We asked a few of the hosts from The New Fly Fisher what their go-to fly is for these perfect predators.

fly

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

Mark Melnyk

Burbot streamer – 6 to 8 inches. Many Northern Ontario lakes play home to mudfish, burbot, lingcod, and a variety of other near-bottom-dwelling fish. These flies imitate these pike prey. We often catch northerns with burbot tails sticking out of their throats. For me, the larger the fly the better.

perch streamer pattern

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

Bill Spicer

Any perch pattern that is at least 6 inches long. I like patterns that are made with synthetics as they don’t hold water, and are much easier to cast. Use with a sinking tip line. The next is a little harder to cast, the red and white bunny leach of at least 6 inches. Pike love red and white.

fly pattern slider black and orange

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

Colin McKeown

I’m a self-proclaimed topwater nut! If I can catch northern pike on topwater, I’m going to do it – and do it all day long! There is nothing like the crushing violence of seeing a pike, no matter the size, murdering a fly! My first go-to fly is a Weedman’s Slider in black or chartreuse. These flies can be fished solely as a topwater or as its name suggest, as a just under-the-surface slider. Still very visible to the angler and 100% fun!

fly pattern thunder chicken

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

Another great topwater pattern that is my go-to is called a Thunder Chicken. It is a very large fly that moves a tonne of water. The water movement will call fish in from afar as they are very curious by nature. I also replace the treble hook with a j hook to minimize any damage to the fish. Deadly pattern and a great deal of fun to throw and retrieve.

angler fishing for northern pike

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

So there you have it. The top five flies for northern pike from our hosts at The New Fly Fisher. If you haven’t had the opportunity to target northern pike in Northern Ontario, you’re really missing out on a tonne of fun. They are aggressive, mean, big and toothy. Just a blast to catch and release on the fly!

For a few great pike locations, please check us out at www.thenewflyfisher.com and www.northernontario.travel

About Mark Melnyk

Currently, Mark is the host and producer of The New Fly Show. With a passion of fly fishing, the shows goal is to help both novice and veteran fly fishers everywhere by giving them a top-quality fly fishing series that will make them better anglers. 

Recommended Articles

Hand to Hand Combat

Experience Crappie Fishing in Ontario

Incredible Walleye

Drive-to Fishing at Brennan Harbour Resort

Steelhead Fever

Fishing in Northwestern Ontario

Lost Lake Bass Blast

Experience Lost Lake Wilderness Lodge and fish on a remote lake filled with Smallmouth Bass.

Chiblow Lake Smallmouth Adventures

The Extreme Angler visits Algoma Country.

Eagle Lake Lunge

When Musky fishing in Northwest Ontario on Eagle Lake, you're one cast from being a hero.

The Blind Leading The Blind

Fly Fishing made Simple, but Not on Purpose

Late Season Panfish

Catch panfish on hardwater with these tips and tricks.

How to Get Into Fishing

You haven't gone fishing in years, how in the world would you get started?

Casual Canadian Muskies

Here’s a simple approach that can have you holding a Canadian musky in no time.

A Fool for Lac Seul

Years of dreams finally materializing, Lac Seul teaches a tough lesson

Road Trip Challenge

5 fishing holes, one weekend.

Goulais River Muskie

Excellent fishing exists within a two-mile stretch near the mouth of Lake Superior.

SPECTACULAR BASS

Fishing for Largemouth Bass in the Parry Sound District

Soo Guides

Three guides will help you tackle that trophy fish.

Landing Lake Trout at Camp Quetico

Choose from 40+ lakes in the heart of Quetico Provincial Park

Spring Perch Fishing

Use These Tips on Your Next Ontario Fishing Trip

Catching Bucket List Walleyes at Dogtooth Lake Resort

The Ontario Experience visits Dogtooth Lake in Sunset Country

Pleasant Cove Resort

Setting sights on Georgian Bay Northern Pike

Reid's Birch Island Resort

Drive-to Fishing in a Remote Setting