Top Flies for Northern Pike

Fishing Tips From the hosts of The New Fly Fisher

There is little arguing that the northern pike is the most dominant fish to swim in the freshwater systems of Northern Ontario. They are relentless hunters which will often lay in wait for their prey to casually swim by and be devoured. They are meat-eaters and often will take fish that are extremely large offerings. When we target northern pike in the fly fishing world, we do our best to imitate these big offerings by throwing big flies for big pike. We asked a few of the hosts from The New Fly Fisher what their go-to fly is for these perfect predators.

fly

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

Mark Melnyk

Burbot streamer – 6 to 8 inches. Many Northern Ontario lakes play home to mudfish, burbot, lingcod, and a variety of other near-bottom-dwelling fish. These flies imitate these pike prey. We often catch northerns with burbot tails sticking out of their throats. For me, the larger the fly the better.

perch streamer pattern

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

Bill Spicer

Any perch pattern that is at least 6 inches long. I like patterns that are made with synthetics as they don’t hold water, and are much easier to cast. Use with a sinking tip line. The next is a little harder to cast, the red and white bunny leach of at least 6 inches. Pike love red and white.

fly pattern slider black and orange

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

Colin McKeown

I’m a self-proclaimed topwater nut! If I can catch northern pike on topwater, I’m going to do it – and do it all day long! There is nothing like the crushing violence of seeing a pike, no matter the size, murdering a fly! My first go-to fly is a Weedman’s Slider in black or chartreuse. These flies can be fished solely as a topwater or as its name suggest, as a just under-the-surface slider. Still very visible to the angler and 100% fun!

fly pattern thunder chicken

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

Another great topwater pattern that is my go-to is called a Thunder Chicken. It is a very large fly that moves a tonne of water. The water movement will call fish in from afar as they are very curious by nature. I also replace the treble hook with a j hook to minimize any damage to the fish. Deadly pattern and a great deal of fun to throw and retrieve.

angler fishing for northern pike

(Photo credit: The New Fly Fisher)

So there you have it. The top five flies for northern pike from our hosts at The New Fly Fisher. If you haven’t had the opportunity to target northern pike in Northern Ontario, you’re really missing out on a tonne of fun. They are aggressive, mean, big and toothy. Just a blast to catch and release on the fly!

For a few great pike locations, please check us out at www.thenewflyfisher.com and www.northernontario.travel

About Mark Melnyk

Currently, Mark is the host and producer of The New Fly Show. With a passion of fly fishing, the shows goal is to help both novice and veteran fly fishers everywhere by giving them a top-quality fly fishing series that will make them better anglers. 

Recommended Articles

3 Secret Tips for Landing Ontario Muskies

Muskies aren’t easy to catch. So here’s a simple formula to change that.

Mashkinonje Lodge

During our short stay we caught and released several trophy smallies over five-pounds.

Smashing Topwater Smallmouth in the Heart of Walleye Country

From spacious, spotlessly clean cottages to aggressive multi-species action.

Lac Seul Lunkers

Non-Stop Walleye Fishing Action

Ice Perchin’ Ontario

Providing Great Fun to Adults and Children Alike

Sweet Spot Season

When you have a limited amount of time to be out there fishing, you really want to look for those high percentage sweet spots.

Dropshot the Shallows

A Technique That Should Be in Your Fishing Arsenal

French River Fever

This waterway is rich in lunge lore, having produced muskies in excess of 60 pounds.

3 Surefire Strategies for Canadian Muskies

Fishing for Ontario Musky

Portage Paradise Walleye

Remote lake fishing adventures to pristine lakes.

Hello Summertime Crappies

Crappies have a reputation for being much harder to find and catch in the lazy hazy crazy days of summer

3 Must Fish Ontario Hotspots for Smallmouth Bass

Everyone has a bucket list for something. Die-hard bass anglers have many.

The Eagle has Landed

If you're looking to make your Ontario fishing dreams come true, this is the place to do it.

Glide to Success

The province of Ontario has more muskie waters than anywhere else on Earth!

Horwood Lake Lodge

Summertime Bass and Walleye from Horwood Lake in Northeastern Ontario

Bass Fishing at Agnew Lake Lodge

This family-owned lodge is the perfect base for excellent angling adventures in Northeastern Ontario.

Fly Casting In The Wind

Use these tips to help make it easier to when out fly fishing in Ontario.

Gear Up for the Fish of Ten Thousand Casts

Preparation is the only thing standing between you and the trophy musky of a lifetime at Cedar Lake Lodge.

Veteran Grit vs. High-Tech Odds: The Ultimate Algoma Derby Showdown

Facing off against a powered-up duo and a technological disadvantage in a length-based battle across the pristine waters of Whitefish and Manitouwik Lakes.

Bob Izumi searches for bass and pike

Fishing unfamiliar territory, Bob Izumi lands monster smallies and Northern pike