Fish the Islands for Canadian Musky Success

A simple strategy for catching muskies is to fish as many islands as possible. It can be big or small islands, these are the places where to find this trophy fish.

There is no question that Ontario is my favourite place to chase muskies. The waters are large, there are hundreds of spots to fish, and the scenery and wildlife are amazing. Fishing Ontario is an experience; it’s not just about catching fish. Of course, I just can’t ignore the fact that there are also more big muskies located in shallow water than anywhere else, and you simply never get bored fishing Canadian waters. With more big muskies shallow, your odds of catching them are greatly increased, so why fish anywhere else?

I honestly have a relatively simple strategy for catching muskies in most Canadian waters. It’s fish as many islands as possible. Big islands or small islands, it really doesn’t matter. Islands are a mecca for holding muskies, and not only do the muskies often show up, but they also reveal a lot about other areas in the lake where you can find them.

Not all islands are created equal, so let’s make this relatively easy and categorize them into giant, medium and little islands. Little islands are those where you can virtually put your trolling motor down and cast around the entire island in less than 30 minutes. Giant islands are those that might be a mile or longer and half a mile wide or even more. The medium islands are everything in between and giant island and a little island.

Giant Islands

I often start my day fishing on a giant Canadian island. I’ll look for a musky spot on that island that contains a large bay.  I’ll start at one of the points, and fish my way from the rocky point, along the shore to the back of the bay. I’ll fish the back of the bay, particularly if it is weedy and continue casting all the way to the next rocky point. While doing this, I am paying attention to where I may encounter muskies. Are they on the points, the back of the bay, or in the transition areas? I’ll fish a couple of similar bays and adjacent points to see if I can figure out a pattern for where the muskies are holding. Then it’s just a matter of fishing more similar spots. If the muskies are in the backs of the weedy bays, I spend the next several hours on those. If they are on the rocky points, I’ll fish more points. The approach is simple, straightforward, and effective.

canadian-muskie-island-3
A classic medium island with three rocky extensions.

Medium Islands

Medium islands are just smaller versions of their giant brothers or sisters. You really don’t want to spend time fishing all around these medium-sized islands, as it could take you an hour or more. However, you can break these medium-sized islands into fishable chunks. The southeast end of every medium island is going to have a softer bottom, due to the glaciers and prevailing winds. So, you will most likely find a weed bed or a rocky or sandy point on the southeast corner. Therefore, always check that side. The North or northwest side will most likely be steeper, but it might also have a few rocky shelves or points from years of erosion. These subtle features can be great, and of course, if you happen to have found muskies on the steeper side of islands, then fish more of the northern side of these islands.

canadian-muskie-island-4
How often do you drive by a little island like this that could be holding a giant Canadian musky?

Little Islands

I love fishing little islands. These are the ones that you can put your trolling motor down and fish around them in 30 minutes. Quite often, musky anglers bypass these little islands. However, they frequently hold one, if not multiple, muskies. I’ll look for groupings of little islands near deeper sections of a Canadian lake and simply move from one little island to another. When the fish are moving and biting, you don’t have to travel far to find muskies. It’s amazing how certain spots on these little islands will consistently hold muskies. It’s almost as if these little islands have specific holding spots. So, any musky cruising may hold on to them temporarily.

All musky lures come into play when fishing islands; however, I would say bucktails, minnow baits, and topwater get the nod most of the time. You are covering water, fishing multiple spots and looking for an active musky to either eat your lure or chase your bait. If they follow, they just told you where they live. You can return later to try and catch them, but in the interim, go fish more spots like the one where the musky showed up.

Keep Calm and Fish the Islands

Canadian waters can be large and seem intimidating. However, keep it simple and fish the islands. Everyone is different and has a unique character. You’ll find each island has lots of potential musky spots, and be truly amazed at how many muskies might be living around one island.

Whether you fish Northwest Ontario or Eastern Ontario, there are musky waters with lots of islands. Start fishing them and before long, you’ll never look at them the same way again, and your dreams will be filled with great musky experiences.

About Jim Saric

Jim owns Jim Saric Outdoors, Inc., which is dedicated to elevating the sport of musky fishing to new levels by educating anglers through print, web, and television. He is the publisher, editor and owner of Musky Hunter Magazine and the Executive Producer of The Musky Hunter television series. Jim has over twenty-five years experience fishing lakes, rivers, and reservoirs from Minnesota to New York and all across Canada. He has boated more than 100 muskies exceeding 50 inches in length, the largest weighing 53 pounds.

Recommended Articles

Twitchbait Smallies

Your guide to open water smallmouth fishing in Atikokan.

Salmon Of The Soo

Fishing for Atlantic Salmon on the St. Marys River.

Top 5 Flies for Smallmouth Bass

The inside scoop on bass flies from the hosts of The New Fly Fisher.

Ghost River Lodges

Remote, Boat-in Fishing on Marchington Lake

True Colours

How important is your lure colour when selecting a bait?

Top 5 Baits for Smallmouth and Largemouth Bass

What baits do you use to target bass? Find out why these 5 are the best!

WOW Summer Whitefish

Whitefish hit harder in the open water season than in the winter

Ice-out glory 

Fish you can target as soon as the ice leaves the launch

Balsam Lake Walleye

How to use snap jigging to catch Ontario walleye.

5 Places to Shore Fish

Fish’n Canada shows you where to go shore fishing in Ontario.

Dog Lake Walleye

This lake has it all, but the incredible walleye fishing is what brought us back

10 Facts About Lake of the Woods

10 facts amazing about this massive Northwest Ontario Lake!

World Class Fishing on the Niagara River

There's always something to target in "Ontario's Grand Canyon"

Angling the Missinaibi

Exploring and fishing the mighty Missinaibi River

Family Fishing Getaway

Jenna sets her sights on Northern Ontario Smallmouth Bass.

20 Years With Fish TV!

Fish TV discusses their favourite Ontario catches

How to Make a Fish Shore Lunch

What to pack and how to make this favourite Northern Ontario meal.

Ned Head Walleye of Algoma

Springtime Walleye Doesn't Have To Be A Crowded Affair

5 Canoe & Kayak Fishing Destinations

Where to go canoe and kayak fishing in Ontario.

Streamers for Big Pike

Northern Pike are the apex predator in many of Ontario’s waters.