The Best Brook Trout Fishing

Ontario is home to the World Record Brook Trout that has kept anglers heading north for generations.

What is there to be said about brook trout that hasn’t already been written, videotaped, or documented? I often sit and wonder how I can present the wonders of this apex predator in a new way. Well, I’ve got a uniquely personal perspective on this species through a few years of hunting for brook trout giants in Ontario’s North. That’s right, I said Ontario. There are specimens in this Canadian province that rival storied brook trout populations around the world.

After all, the world record fish was caught in the Nipigon River in the heart of Ontario’s brook trout country. That fish went a staggering 14.5 lbs. I have a very intimate relationship with these fish. I respect these fish, have never harvested one and most certainly have never eaten one.

brook-trout-ontario-1

Brook trout, despite their spectacular paint job, is actually one of the more violent creatures that swim. If they can fit it in their mouths, they can—sorry they will eat it. On a remote fly-in adventure in the Albany River watershed, I once witnessed a 3-pound brook trout regurgitate an 8- to 10-inch walleye! I have also witnessed 4-inch brook trout eat a 3-inch articulated fly. I have never nymphed for these fish and prefer to throw substantive offerings to them on a fly rod. From surface floating mouse patterns to elongated bunny leeches, my feeling is the feeding window (lack of ice spring-fall) in the north is short so fish will find opportunities in protein offerings. My theory has allowed me to hook 2 fish that estimated bested 10 pounds a few that were in the 7- to 8-pound range and almost countless 5-pound brook trout.

brook-trout-ontario-2

They are hunters looking for maximum benefit for minimum effort. However, the personality of the brook trout is what I find to be unique. Frankly, they are incredible!

brook-trout-ontario-3

The brook trout of Ontario is a very worthy adversary on the fly. Be they the wee specimens of southern Ontario small streams, or the giants of the backcountry, to be a brook trout angler requires a level of commitment—not dissimilar to those who chose to only hunt the elusive musky. Thankfully, brook trout aren’t nearly as few and far between as those toothy critters! However, I have said it umpteen times, brook trout seem to be an all-or-nothing fish. If they aren’t eating readily, you’ll have to get down and dirty for them and it’ll be work! But when they are on, they are on! And it’s worth every single effort in their pursuit. The other commitment associated with brook trout is the bugs. Brookies live where the bugs live and for whatever reason, they seem to go hand in hand, so you’ll need to be prepared for that. Consider yourself warned!

brook-trout-ontario-4

brook-trout-ontario-5

The pursuit of brook trout has an extremely personal benefit for me as well. Brook trout live in some pretty spectacular places and are pursued by some pretty spectacular people. Like-minded individuals, with a common goal often in remote environments where you can’t simply get up and leave. Many of the people I’ve fished brook trout with have become friends with whom I keep in touch and can’t wait to fish with again.

brook-trout-ontario-6

brook-trout-ontario-7

Bottom line: it’s just fishing and brook trout is just a fish…but they're fish with benefits that far exceed the pure joy I feel watching them swim away. If you haven’t ever fished brook trout in the streams, rivers and lakes of Ontario, do yourself a favour and give it a try.

You’ll be amazed at the benefits of this, Mother Nature’s most beautifully painted freshwater fish.

About Mark Melnyk

Currently, Mark is the host and producer of The New Fly Show. With a passion of fly fishing, the shows goal is to help both novice and veteran fly fishers everywhere by giving them a top-quality fly fishing series that will make them better anglers. 

Recommended Articles

Six Species on Six Lakes at Slippery Winds

The Ontario Experience visits Sunset Country in sight of endless fish

Lodge 88: Keeping it in the Family

Fish'n Canada host Ang Viola takes his grandson to fly-in fishing lodge Lodge 88 on Esnagi Lake.

Big Moose Camp

Fishing for Trophy Musky on Lake Nosbonsing

White(fish) North

Ontario's Lakes Offer Unlimited Opportunities

Friends in Fishy Times

An ode to fishing buddies new and old

Rainy Lake Walleye

Fishing at La Belle’s Birch Point Camp

Fall Walleye

Using Chub, Bottom Bouncers and Beads

Pro Fishing Photos

Helping You Take Better Photos of Your Catch

Balsam Lake Walleye

How to use snap jigging to catch Ontario walleye.

Crackin' The Code

Tips to Pattern Lake Trout in Ontario

Float Fishing

The Fast Track to Superior Steelhead

Tactical Trophy Trouting

Ice adventures for Lake Trout fishing across Northern Ontario

Making Fishing Memories

There's no better way to start spending time with your family and friends.

The Blind Leading The Blind

Fly Fishing made Simple, but Not on Purpose

Late Season Panfish

Catch panfish on hardwater with these tips and tricks.

How to Get Into Fishing

You haven't gone fishing in years, how in the world would you get started?

Casual Canadian Muskies

Here’s a simple approach that can have you holding a Canadian musky in no time.

A Fool for Lac Seul

Years of dreams finally materializing, Lac Seul teaches a tough lesson

Road Trip Challenge

5 fishing holes, one weekend.

Goulais River Muskie

Excellent fishing exists within a two-mile stretch near the mouth of Lake Superior.