Prodigious Pike Aplenty

It may be getting cold, but Gord has the technique to make pike fishing bountiful—and fun, too

Okay, the temperature is dipping, the wind is feeling frosty, and you may even spot a flurry or two of snow in the air. So, calling it a picnic may be a bit of an overstatement, but that is precisely how I view the fishing for northern pike these days, across all of Northern Ontario.

As a matter of fact, as good as the action can be in the spring, immediately after ice-out, it can be better in the fall, just before it freezes up. As grandson Liam and I discovered the other day when I swung the net under his new personal best-ever northern pike. A beautiful, rotund, 20-pound-plus, big toothy critter.

We were fishing at a favourite fall "bus stop" where over the years I've caught prodigious pike, as well as a slew of knee-knocking muskies. By the way, I call them "bus stops" because the big toothy critters use these select fall locations like kids waiting to hop on and off the bus each day on their way to and from school.

Find one of the gathering areas, or better yet, several on your favourite lake, and even though you'll be wiping drops off the end of your nose all day, you'll think it is a picnic as well.

young angler holding northern pike

Liam Whetter caught his personal best northern pike on the weekend, by concentrating his fishing around the "bus stops" where the big fish congregate in the fall.

The key to selecting the right spot is finding a feeding flat in the 10- to 20-foot depth range on a main structural element, like an underwater point, saddle or hump. The most important fine-tuning detail, however, is that the edge of the structure, the outside rim of the shelf itself, must break or slope quickly into much deeper water.

The big pike, being ambush predators rather than open water stalkers, typically lie just below the rim, waiting to pounce on the unsuspecting pelagic forage fish like ciscoes and whitefish that are typically crossing the plateau on their way to their spawning grounds, or using the drop off to lay their eggs. It doesn't hurt, either, that fall walleyes and suckers also hang out on these pantry shelves and are often served up as the dinner special of the day.

angler holding northern pike

As Gord Pyzer explains, the best fall pike structures always break quickly into deep water.

When the weather is pleasant, I like to park the boat out off the edge in deeper water and cast a 4 1/2- to 5-inch Storm Wildeye swimbait or Bassmagnet Shift 'R Shad pinned to a 1/2- to 3/4-ounce Freedom Lure Hydra Jig up onto the shelf. I let it settle to the bottom and then retrieve it at a slow to moderate pace back to the boat so that when it reaches the edge, it looks like a confused forage fish venturing out over deeper water and exposing itself to the tooth-filled dangers that lurk below.

Unfortunately, the weather was anything but pleasant the other day when Liam and I were out fishing, so instead of casting, we pulled our rain suits over our heads and stuffed our rods into the holders while I trolled the boat across the shelf, paying particular attention to tracing out the deepwater/shallow water transition.

angler holding northern pike

Casting or trolling your lure around the edges of structures makes it look like a confused forage fish exposing itself to the tooth-filled dangers that lurk below.

There was no surprise what we were trolling, either, because I have come to rely over the years on 4 ½-inch half gold/half silver Williams Whitefish spoons. I always replace the factory treble with a single Gamakatsu Siwash hook. And this day, to keep them swinging back and forth, close to the bottom, I tied 3/8-ounce Bead Chain Keel Sinkers ahead of our lures.

angler releasing northern pike

The bulging bellies that big pike exhibit in the fall are signs the fish are developing the eggs they will lay next spring.  Best to release the fish to spawn again.

The combination has been gold for producing giant northern pike in the past, but lately, I have been adding a secret dressing to the spoon that takes it over the top and makes it platinum. It is one of my good friends Art Gaetan's Herring Cove Bait Strip. Art hand cuts and cures the filets from wild Atlantic herring using a super-salty brine that firms them up so they stay on your hook, and yet remain pliable when you troll them on a spoon. Even better still, as he likes to say, the strips stink in the best possible way.

young angler holding northern pike

To which I can attest, because after Liam landed his trophy and then set it free, I wiped away a water droplet from the end of my nose, and I could smell Art's odoriferous super-salty herring strip for the rest of the day. Reminding me vividly, for hours afterwards, that fishing for prodigious pike in the fall, in Northern Ontario, is a picnic.

About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Top 10 Ice Fishing Lakes

Every kind of fish and experience—Ontario ice fishing is some of the best in the world.

Terrestrial Flies for Brook Trout

These fish feed like crazy and look for opportunities for a big protein meal.

5 Deadliest Fishing Lures

Use these lures when ice fishing for lake trout in Northern Ontario.

Spring Perch Fishing

Use These Tips on Your Next Ontario Fishing Trip

Luxury Meets Remote on Kenora’s Lake of the Woods

Discover the ultimate outpost destination for fishing, hunting, and outdoor adventure.

3 Great Ontario Walleye Destinations

Karl of Extreme Angler recommends must do walleye lakes in Ontario.

Fishing On The French

Fish TV Stay At Bears Den Lodge

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

HIdden Bay Lodge

Fly-in to Armit Lake for Epic Walleye Fishing

Drive-to Ontario Lodges

Ontario has the perfect easy-to-access fishing oasis for every angler!

The Eyes Have it

How to Use a Natural Resource as Bait

Real Fishing at Mattawa River Resort

Mattawa River Resort offers an easy to get to location and unlimited fishing opportunities

Big Lake Abitibi

Ice Fishing With Dunn Right Outfitters

Whitefish Lake Walleye

An epic walleye fishing adventure in Superior Country.

Don’t Be Afraid Of Muskies

Muskies are fish of 10,000 casts and are found in large bodies of water in Northwestern Ontario.

Horwood Lake Lodge

Summertime Bass and Walleye from Horwood Lake in Northeastern Ontario

Long Nose Gar

A Fish for the Bucket List

Year Round Fishing in Ontario

Who Says You Can’t Fish All Year in Ontario?

Don't Let the Name Perch Lake Fool You

These Northern Ontario waters are packed with northern pike like you'll never believe, abundant gourmet walleye, and yellow perch await.

Predicting Lake Thickness

When Will Ontario Lakes Freeze Over This Winter?