Paradise for the Adventurous Angler

Fishing in Lake Superior Provincial Park

Have you ever thought about taking a fishing trip deep into Ontario's north? Maybe a place surrounded by pristine lakes, rivers and even a Great Lake? Are you looking for a place that boasts world-class trout fishing year-round? Do you want a sense of adventure? Well, Lake Superior Provincial Park is a destination for all of the above!

Fishing in the park is phenomenal for brook trout, lake trout and splake (lake trout/brook trout hybrid). The tributaries that run into Lake Superior from the park are teeming with migratory rainbow trout in the spring and are accompanied by pink, Coho and Chinook salmon during the fall run.

Photo credit: Tyler Dunn Guiding

Brook Trout

The brook trout fishing stands out as the most desired for anglers visiting the park. The options are endless with lakes found right off Highway 17. Many lakes are just short portages, although most of the interior portages can be quite gruelling. Brookies in the park range from 12 - 18 inches on average but anglers have a good shot at breaking the 20-inch mark on many of the lakes.

Open water tactics for brookies include both trolling and casting. Spring usually calls for casting shallow pulling fish off rocky points, boulder-strewn shorelines, beaver dams and downed trees. Summer fishing is best done deeper, targeting fish in the 15- to 20-foot depths, especially on or near rocky shoals that have deep water access nearby.

Fall brook trout fishing can go either way. Depending on the water temperatures, these fish will either still be related to deep water or will begin to venture shallow; closer to the spawning grounds. One thing is for sure, they will be putting the fall feedbag on in preparation for the upcoming spawn. Cast spoons in various sizes from 1/4 - 3/4 ounces such as Little Cleos or other similar spoons. A slow retrieve with the odd pause, flutter and pop retrieve will put brookies into your canoe or kayak all year. Top-producing spoon colours have always been silver/blue and gold/orange but don't be shy to experiment. Inline spinners in sizes #3 - #5 have their days as do small bucktail jigs up to 3/8 of an ounce.

tyler dunn 6sm
Photo credit: Tyler Dunn Guiding

Remember, most fish in the spring are caught in 10 feet or less so make long casts and try and stay as stealthy as possible. These lakes are extremely clear so spooking fish is always a possibility. Top producing flies for anglers to try are woolly buggers in black, orange, white and olive.

Leech patterns and small streamers in natural colours always seem to receive consistent takes, especially during low light conditions in the mornings and evenings when the trout are cruising shallow to feed. A slow retrieve is best with flies too. I typically recommend a strip, strip, stop (count to 5), strip, strip, stop retrieve. Caddis and hex hatches give fly anglers the opportunity to get into some nymph fishing which I often like to use on a dropper rig below a streamer. At certain times of the year, fly anglers can also experience extremely hot dry fly action throughout the late spring and summer.

tyler dunn 2sm
Photo credit: Tyler Dunn Guiding

Lake Trout

Lake Superior Park lake trout are underfished in my eyes. Some of the bigger lakes host generous populations of lake trout ranging from 3 - 6 pounds. These fish hit hard, fight hard and are extremely dark in appearance compared to other lake trout in the area of Algoma. Trolling, jigging and casting catches lake trout in the spring, summer and fall. The cold water temperature of spring brings many lakers in extremely shallow for the first month of fishing. Twenty feet of water and even less on some days is where you want to concentrate your fishing. A 7-foot medium spinning rod works best for casting spoons, tube jigs, cranks and spinners and also doubles as a great jigging rod.

Baits such as tube jigs, twister tails, soft plastic minnows, Swedish pimples or various casting and jigging spoons all work well. I like to troll with a 7-foot medium-action fibreglass bait casting rod. The rod has enough backbone for any lake trout and offers an extremely soft tip which acts as a great shock absorber when trolling big lures and heavyweights in the summer.

lspp laketrout tylerdunn
Photo credit: Tyler Dunn Guiding

Fly fishing for these beauties is quite the thrill. During May and June, the lake trout as I mentioned before are relatively shallow, especially when on the feed. Casting the shallows (20 feet and under) is usually done with white, white/black, chartreuse or olive-coloured streamers.

Once the lakers move to deeper water and relate to the 40-feet-plus depths. A sink tip and some lead are often needed to keep your fly down to the strike zone. Not only are these trout after minnow imitation flies, but lakers are also eager to take crayfish and smaller offerings, so nymphs definitely have their time and place in your laker arsenal. An 8- or 9-weight rod in the 8- or 9-foot length is what I recommend for a rod when targeting lakers from a canoe or kayak in the park.

Steelhead and Salmon

During the high waters and Spring and Fall, migratory steelhead fill the rivers. This is without a doubt my favourite time to fish Lake Superior's north shore. Highway 17 north of Sault Ste. Marie is polluted with streams and rivers full of fish. The water level is the biggest factor in timing runs on these clear, freezing-cold rivers. Floating fishing with center pin reels is my personal favourite method for catching these silvery, rocket ships. A Raven RV9 or Im8, 13-foot float rod is the ideal rod for float fishing these tributaries. Even though Lake Superior rainbow trout are generally smaller in size when compared to the other Great Lake fisheries. What they lack in size, is made up with the unreal power they possess. These fish are extremely strong especially when the water temps warm up in the late spring and early fall.

Casting hardware or bouncing bottom with an eight- to nine-foot spinning rod is always an effective method. Fly anglers will have a blast swinging flies as well as nymphing. An 8-weight fly rod in the 8- to 9-foot length with a large arbour reel is recommended for tackling these squirrely fish if fly fishing is our choice.

tyler dunn 3sm
Photo credit: Tyler Dunn Guiding

Lake Superior Park offers the most adventurous ice fishing anglers some spectacular opportunities on Lake Superior on years with cold winters. Steelhead and salmon can both be caught through the ice in February, March and into April.

tyler dunn 4sm
Photo credit: Tyler Dunn Guiding

Lake Superior Provincial Park offers summertime campgrounds throughout the entire park. Visitors of Lake Superior Park have the option of staying at one of the 3 campgrounds that offer electricity, washrooms and even laundry facilities. Many use these as a home base and travel each day to a different part of the park to experience one of the many unique attractions. Many other campers/anglers choose to set camp up at one of the interior park campsites. There are 200 backcountry campsites available for visitors to use if "off the grid" interior camping is desired.

Other activities Lake Superior Provincial Park offers are 11 hiking trails, 8 canoe routes, the abandoned fishing village of Gargantua Harbour, a visitor center and the famous Agawa Rock Pictographs.

Photo credit: Tyler Dunn Guiding

Fishing in the park can be best described as good for the soul. The lakes are typically cold, crystal clear and full of trout. You will be delighted to find that more often than not you will be the only other anglers on the lake. For more information on fishing contact me at

tyler dunn 8sm
Photo credit: Tyler Dunn Guiding
About Tyler Dunn

Tyler Dunn is a year-round multi-species guide and outdoor writer from Sault Ste. Marie.

Recommended Articles

Lake Superior

10 Facts You Might Not Have Known About Lake Superior

The Wawa Goose

Welcoming Visitors For Over 50 Years

Eye Opener

Best Bait, Lures and Scents to Catch Walleye

Old Woman Bay

A Must Stop on Lake Superior

Early Season Pike

Learn How to Target These Big Fish

Facts About Lake Huron

10 Things We Bet You Didn't Know

You Gotta Eat Here: 5 Must Try Restaurants in Sault Ste. Marie

These restaurants are a must when visiting the Soo.

Winnie-the-Pooh's Ontario origins

Learn the History of World's Most Beloved Bear

The Ultimate Group of Seven Road Trip

See the inspirations for their greatest works.

Bringing Home Fish

Understanding Ontario Fishing Regulations

Fresh Fish Fries

Fish'n Chips, All You Can Eat & Specials in Algoma

Pike and Muskie Leaders

When to Use Them and What Types To Use

Drop Shot Walleye

Learn This Effective Fishing Technique

Minnows, Leeches, Nightcrawlers

Which Bait is Best for Walleye

Gargantua Harbour and Warp Bay

Lake Superior Provincial Park Never Disappoints

Group of Seven Touring Route

21 Panels, Mobile App to Experience the Landscape

Experience Crown land camping

5 Places to Crown land Camp in Algoma and 7 Ways to Do it Right

A Trip into the Past

With the Mennonites of Algoma

The Butter Tart

Oh, Butter Tart, We Stand on Guard for Thee

Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald

The Best Song About Lake Superior