Cat Island Lodge

In short, it was the most fantastic lake trout fishing I have ever experienced, with fish topping over 20 pounds.

I would guess most people (not all, of course) travel to Ontario in search of catching walleyes, whether it be catching 100-plus walleyes a day or in search of a 30-inch-plus trophy walleye of a lifetime. I know it's one fish species that tops my list to target. That said, pretty much all the lakes across Ontario are filled with multi-species opportunities.

Cat Island Lodge, located in Sunset Country, Ontario, is one of those multi-species destinations and a place I had been to a few years ago. On the previous trip, my emphasis was on the amazing lake trout fishing they have to offer. In short, it was the most fantastic lake trout fishing I have ever experienced, with numbers and fish topping over 20 pounds. But I also caught a ton of walleye that were mixed in with the lake trout that were moving shallow staging to spawn in the fall.

angler holding walleye

Photo credit: The Ontario Experience

Arriving at the dock of Cat Island Lodge and stepping off the plane, you know it will be one of those "this is going to be great" trips. Their fantastic service is a strong commitment to ensuring that their guest's vacation is an experience to remember. Cat Island Lodge is a full-service, luxury fly-in fishing resort located on beautiful Trout Lake with over 99,000 acres of water to fish. They have an all-inclusive American Plan that includes comfortable 18-foot Lund and Crestliner boats with reliable 40-hp 4-stroke motors and Humminbird sonars.

Cat Island Lodge offers a beautiful and cozy main lodge for relaxing and enjoying your delicious meals. The log construction gives it a rustic charm that fits the natural surroundings, and the views overlooking the lake are breathtaking. They serve a hearty breakfast in the dining room, walleye or lake trout shore lunch around noon, and a complete evening dinner menu featuring a variety of delicious family-style meals.

scenic view cat island lodge

Photo credit: The Ontario Experience

On this trip, I wanted to focus mainly on walleye fishing. The lake is a typical Canadian Shield lake with islands, shoreline breaks, and neck-down areas with moving water. Perfect spots to find schools of hungry walleye.

I spent my mornings targeting walleye in 18 to 25 feet of water where we took advantage of some fast and steady catch-and-release action. However, we kept a limit of eaters under 18 inches for our shore lunch. Trout Lake has trophy-class walleye, but the average-sized fish are equally impressive, with an average size of 18 to 22 inches. During fall, there are also big schools of walleye hanging out in that 30-foot-plus range, but it's a good idea to avoid walleye in those depths. Unlike lake trout, pulling walleyes out of deep water increases the mortality rate of the fish to nearly 100%.

ontario shore lunch

Photo credit: The Ontario Experience

Jig and minnows are an effective and excellent way to find active pods of fish. Still, artificial baits can be equally effective and allow you to have your line in the water more often without constantly re-baiting. A jig and soft plastics, such as a minnow profile, paddle tail, or grubs, are deadly combinations. A Rapala Jiggin' Rap, Rippin' Rap, and VMC hair jigs are also highly effective vertical presentations for walleye.

I would never visit Cat Island Lodge without spending some time fishing for lake trout. So each afternoon, I would target those hard-fighting, deep cold-water fish. Vertically jigging glow white 3/4- to 1-ounce jigs with pearl-coloured minnow profile soft plastics was the ticket. I had most of my strikes when seeing a school of lake trout on my sonar, reeling up quickly pulling the baits away from them. They seemed to be in chase mode instead of just having the bait dangle and teased in front of them. When they hit the bait, they would crush it, and the fight was on.

When picking your next fishing adventure, Cat Island Lodge should be at the top of your list. Revisiting soon is a definite for me. I think I'll target the giant pike in Trout Lake this time giant pike giant pike residing in Trout Lake.

For more information on Cat Island Lodge, please visit: www.exc-adventures.com
For more information on Sunset Country, please visit:visitsunsetcountry.com

About Ty Sjodin

Ty Sjodin is the co-host of The Ontario Experience airing on The Sportsman Channel, The Sportsman Channel—Canada, and the World Fishing Network (WFN).  He enjoys traveling across Ontario, experiencing everything the province and lodges have to offer—including the amazing hunting and multi-species fishing! Ty can’t remember when he wasn’t outside fishing or hunting, but it was about the same time he started to walk. He has a strong passion for the outdoors that was instilled in him by his father and has been shared with his older brother to this day. That is the same passion he now shares with his son, Tyson. Ty spent his college years earning a Business Management / Sales Degree at Bemidji State University, while feeding his obsession of being outdoors in a boat, on the ice, on his bow hunting stands, in the duck blind or shooting grouse. Getting his start in the fishing industry, Ty went to work for In-Fisherman joining the Lindner’s in 1998 to sell everything from TV, print and digital advertising as well as working with and promoting the In-Fisherman Professional Walleye Trial (PWT). After 10 years he moved on to sell TV and digital advertising in the hunting industry as well as fishing for Babe Winkelman Productions for the next 6 years. Ty has come full circle rejoining the Lindner’s once again, now at Lindner Media Productions handling the multi-media sales efforts as well as some on-camera talent.

Recommended Articles

Spring Has Sprung

Grassroots organizations like the Georgian Triangle Anglers Association have stocked trout in Georgian Bay for over 30 years.

Perfect Fall Fishing

Fishing Bass in Kawarthas & Northumberland

Fish Photos 2

Learn to take bolder photos with these tips!

Coffee, Fish, Repeat

Fishing for Smallmouth Bass and Muskie

Buck Lake Lodge

Fishing Walleye at Witches Nose

Hawk Lake Lodge

Drive-in fishing with giant fish results

Planning for Pike

Start Planning for Trophy Fishing

Lost Lake Bass Blast

Experience Lost Lake Wilderness Lodge and fish on a remote lake filled with Smallmouth Bass.

Chiblow Lake Smallmouth Adventures

The Extreme Angler visits Algoma Country

Eagle Lake Lunge

When Musky fishing in Northwest Ontario on Eagle Lake, you're one cast from being a hero.

Fishing Northern Lights Country

Whitefish Lake is Great for Adventuring Angler

World Class Carp

Ontario is a World-Class Fishery for Carp

Reasons to Fish Thunder Bay

It’s worth the trip to fish and visit Canada’s premier outdoor city!

How to Get Into Fishing

You haven't gone fishing in years, how in the world would you get started?

Casual Canadian Muskies

Here’s a simple approach that can have you holding a Canadian musky in no time.

A Fool for Lac Seul

Years of dreams finally materializing, Lac Seul teaches a tough lesson

Shield Lakes & Rivers

A Million Acres of Water. Where do You Start?

5 Flies for Ontario’s Most Popular Species

In these northern waters live of the most revered fish anglers wish to target on fly.

Northern Ontario is Great for Fall Bass

Learn the best regions for fall bass fishing.

A Houseboat Adventure

The Ontario Experience visits Lac Seul in search of huge muskie