Prime Time for Ontario Panfish

The best time to ice fish for panfish is...
Image 03.JPG

What do you do when you look at your favourite fishing app and see that the metrics are predicting a super slow bite? I mean, they’re so dull and uneventful that the activity level is falling off the deep end of the “sluggish” mode.

Honest truth, in all of the time I’ve been using the free MHTV app, I have never seen the activity level run along the zero axis. But that is precisely where it was lying on January 14th, when my grandson Liam and I headed out on the ice to fish for crappies on our favourite Sunset Country lake.

But guess what? The activity level was off the charts good. As a matter of fact, I landed a beautiful pie plate-shaped crappie on my very first drop down the hole. Better yet, the action stayed at this torrid pace for the rest of the day.

primetime-panfish-1
Free fishing apps like MHTV tell you the best times to hit the ice, but you need to be able to interpret the data for your favourite species.

That hardly sounds like a ringing endorsement for the app, does it? But, as it turns out, it was stunning support. You see the fishing app (and other predictors like it) weaves together three broad categories of metrics. First, there are the things that evolve slowly over time, like the lake basin characteristics, water transparency and forage base. Second are the conditions that shift weekly or monthly, like moon phases, seasonal fish migrations and spawning activity. Finally, we have the elements that change constantly — on a daily basis — like moonrise, moonset, wind speed, sun position and cloud cover. When you factor in and consider all of these variables collectively, they do a marvellous job of predicting when big predators are going to feed. See where I am going with this?

primetime-panfish-2
The best time to catch jumbo perch and black crappies is when predator activity is low.

I have to give Liam credit for picking up on it initially. He had noticed a year or two ago that we often experienced delirious yellow perch and crappie fishing on days when the App predicted measly results.

primetime-panfish-3
Passive metrics for predators mean prime time for panfish.

“Have you noticed,” he said to me the other day, as we relaxed inside our two-man EVO pop-up shelter with the heater cranked up to cherry red, “that we typically have our best crappie and perch fishing when the app predicts the most sluggish activity? I think it is because the big predators like northern pike, muskies, lake trout and walleyes aren’t feeding. So the panfish feel free to move around and forage out in the open, and suspend in the water column without worrying about being picked off and eaten.”

“Whoa," I thought. "You know what, he's right."  

Think about all the times you’ve watched underwater videos of big apex predators.  Often you will see much smaller baitfish hanging around with them, swimming and feeding nonchalantly, as though they don’t have a care in the world. They behave like a herd of gazelles grazing on the savannah, while a pride of lions doze away on the grassy sidelines. But then something shifts, an unheard dinner bell rings, the forage goes on alert, and they sense their lives are suddenly in danger.    

primetime-panfish-4
Photo Credit: Gord Pyzer

“I think the app predicts well the activity level of the predators,” Liam said, “and when it is extremely low, fish like crappies, yellow perch and herring know they’re less at risk. So they take advantage of the safe conditions and feed aggressively. What this means is that the peak period for panfish is when the metrics are low and sluggish for lake trout, northern pike, muskies and walleye. Passive metrics for predators means prime time for pannies.”

primetime-panfish-5
Photo Credit: Gord Pyzer
primetime-panfish-6
As Gord Pyzer explains, when big predators are active panfish activity can be slow, and vice versa.

It really makes sense when you think about it and highlights a potentially potent tool for helping you decide what species to target on any individual day out on the ice in Northern Ontario. If the metrics are positive and high, zero in on the bigger toothy predators. And when they’re negative and low, rub your hands together in glee and go after yellow perch, crappies and herring.

About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Fly Fishing at Anderson's Lodge

A smallmouth bass fly fishing adventure to this famous lodge on Lac Seul.

’Tis The Season

Get ready for ice fishing with these tips for landing panfish.

A Guide to Fly-in Ontario Lodges

Today’s fly-in fishing vacations are no more expensive than most other getaways.

Hidden Musky Gems

The Musky Hunter shares 3 favourite musky hot spots across Ontario.

Abitibi Walleye Experience

Fishing for Walleye, Northern Pike and Jumbo Perch

Discover the 3 Best Bass Fishing Lakes in Ontario

Check out these lakes for hard-fighting smallmouth bass on your next fishing trip to Northern Ontario.

An Amazing New Technique for Northern Pike

Learn the latest winter Northern pike pattern to hit the Northern Ontario ice scene.

Fishing for Ontario Wild Brook Trout At Northern Skies Resort

Targeting wild brook in the local rivers, creeks and streams of Algoma Country, Ontario.

Cutler Lake Lodge: Your Cozy North Channel Area Fishing Getaway

Where exceptional hospitality and fantastic multi-species fishing meet.

Sliding Into Bass Heaven

Fall is approaching, and they need to start feeding for the winter.

Legend of the White worm

Learn to Fish for Bass With This Lure

Pro Fishing Photos

Helping You Take Better Photos of Your Catch

Crackin' The Code

Tips to Pattern Lake Trout in Ontario

Tactical Trophy Trouting

Ice adventures for Lake Trout fishing across Northern Ontario

The Complete Wilderness Experience with Air Dale

Air Dale offers drive-in and fly-in trips for some of the finest wilderness fishing and hunting in Algoma Country.

Ontario Brook Trout

Fish these 10 sweet spots.

HIdden Bay Lodge

Fly-in to Armit Lake for Epic Walleye Fishing

Trophy Lake Trout and Smallmouth Under the Northern Lights

The Ontario Experience visits Clarks Resort in Ontario's Sunset Country

Manitoulin Island Fishing

Lake Huron offers a wide variety of freshwater species

Tomiko Lake Lodge

An Outstanding Resort for Fishing and Families