The Tigers Of Sunset Country

It's a bucket list fish. Here's why Sunset Country is the best place to catch a tiger musky.

The tiger musky. Just the thought of it amazes most anglers. The most picturesque of all freshwater fish. With the beautiful tiger-like stripes and vivid contrast of the colours, anglers from all over the musky range come to Sunset Country with one goal. To check the elusive tiger musky off the bucket list.

sunset country tiger musky

What Is A Tiger Musky?

The tiger, or hybrid musky is a natural cross-breeding of a Northern Pike and Musky, resulting in a sterile offspring, the tiger musky. Well known due to their distinctive tiger stripe markings. 

Sunset Country Muskies

All over Sunset Country the lakes are full of muskies but many anglers fish these waters every year and never catch a tiger musky. While our area is known to produce tiger muskies, not every lake is going to have a fishable population of hybrids. 

I am fortunate to fish all the great tiger musky waters around Sunset Country. So prevalent is the tiger musky that ten to twenty percent of my annual catches will be tigers. Visiting Sunset Country with the hope of catching a tiger? Ask the local lodge owners about tiger muskies in their lakes, and ask at local tackle and bait shops. Search social media. To catch a tiger, you have to be on water that has an abundance of tigers.

What To Expect?

Tiger muskies are generally shorter and stockier than a musky. The head seems large compared to the body and the tail is often stubby or short. The average size in Northwestern Ontario is 28 inches to 38 inches, fish over 40 inches are considered large tigers. Hybrid musky at 45 inches or larger are considered true trophy fish. Many musky anglers would consider a 45-inch tiger the equivalent of a 50-inch musky, only harder to catch.

couple fishing tiger musky

You Found A Lake, Now What?

Tiger muskies act much more like the parent pike than a pure-bred musky. Meaning, smaller tigers will often be in areas you would consider good habitat for smaller, juvenile pike. Shallow weedy bay, protected rock shoals etc. Smaller tigers can be targeted in the same way as pike in these areas, spoons, spinnerbaits and small bucktails are effective.

tiger musky fishing

Larger tigers act like large northern pike. Most pike anglers will tell you the largest pike in any body of water will be out in the basin, close to deep water. This is where we find large tigers in open water. One area we consistently find big tigers is current areas. Creek mouths, river mouths or outflow areas with lots of current always seem to hold plenty of bait and tiger musky seem to enjoy those areas.

Aggressive By Nature

Aggressive and relentless and without the need to reproduce, (due to being sterile), tiger muskies eat often and grow fast. Growth rates on average are nearly twice as fast as pure-bred muskies. In lake systems with tigers, the tiger musky will be much more aggressive than the pure-bred muskies. This past season, using forward-facing sonar we were able to see this in real-time. In areas with multiple fish on the sonar, the fish that were the most aggressive towards our baits were almost always tigers.

late fall tiger musky

These larger hybrids, while generally more aggressive, are harder to find in any given body of water. Fishing the aforementioned areas, deep current areas seem to be our best-producing area. With the addition of forward-facing sonar technology, we have been able to find bait in deeper water, and subsequently, muskies and tigers. Baits that excel in deeper applications are key to success. Red October 10-inch monster tube, Lake X Toad, deep diving crankbaits and classic dive and rise baits like the Suick Thriller.

Fall fishing continually produces trophy tiger muskies for us, year after year. The aggressive nature of the tiger seems to really serve them well during the fall whitefish and cisco spawn. Using live bait and sucker rigs during the late October bait fish spawn always puts quality tigers in the net. So much so that if you are truly looking for a trophy tiger, you need to book a fall fishing trip in Sunset Country! Trolling in the fall has produced some of the largest tigers for us as well, again find the bait fish and the aggressive tiger will always be close by.

Water, Water, Everywhere

Where to start in Sunset Country? If the goal of the trip is a tiger musky, look to the lakes with a history of tiger musky catches. Almost every lake that has a population of both pike and musky in Sunset Country can potentially see spawning overlap. That being said, not every lake will have a truly fishable population of tiger muskies.

In my experience, your best shot at a tiger musky will be the Indian Lake Chain, Canyon Lake, Cedar Lake and Perrault Lake. Other lakes such as Ord, Thaddeus, Wabigoon, Cliff and Eagle Lake will produce tigers but they are just not caught as often.

I posted a video on this subject on our 54 or Bust YouTube channel, find it here:

The Best TIGER MUSKY Lakes In Northwestern Ontario

tiger musky sunset country

Muskies are notoriously known as the fish of ten thousand casts. For good reason, they do not come easy. Tiger muskies are even harder to catch. Many musky anglers will fish their entire life and never catch one. Many lakes in the United States are stocked with tiger muskies, and they are still tough to catch.

In Northwestern Ontario no stocking of muskies occurs. All tiger muskies are the result of natural cross-breeding. During late springs the spawn of the northern pike and musky will overlap, resulting in cross-breeding. It varies from year to year and is very much related to weather patterns. Currently, the population of fishable tiger muskies is very high, but this peak will change over time. Right now is a perfect time to target muskies, and specifically the tiger musky in Northwestern Ontario.

Fishing in Sunset Country will give many anglers the chance to check the tiger musky off the Bucket List.

About Glenn McDonald

Glenn McDonald grew up in Northwestern Ontario and has been fishing here his entire life. muskies are what Glenn pursues and his skills are second to none. He lives in Vermilion Bay, Ontario. Glenn has an active YouTube Channel where you can view some of the incredible fish he catches and get tips to help you catch more muskies while visiting Sunset Country.

Recommended Articles

The Other Mighty Mighty

Brookies on the Nipigon River

Hearst Air Service

Remote trophy fishing for both walleye and pike.

Tournament Tips

5 Pro Tips to Use This Upcoming Season

Seeing is Believing

Ice fishing when they aren't biting but you can't stop catching fish.

Hello Summertime Crappies

Crappies have a reputation for being much harder to find and catch in the lazy hazy crazy days of summer

Lake of Bays fishing

Smallmouth Bass Fishing in Muskoka

Fly Fishing Basics

Learn Tips From An Avid Angler Towards Initial Fly FIshing Success

The Ultimate Winter Perch Trap

Ice-fishing tips for landing yellow perch

Whitefish Lake Walleye

An epic walleye fishing adventure in Superior Country.

Fishful Dreams Do Come True

Landing my favourite species on back-to-back casts at Cedar Lake Camp

Best Bass Baits for Lodge Trips

Sure-fire baits and techniques that have resulted in success at Northern Ontario fishing lodges

3 Must Fish Ontario Hotspots for Smallmouth Bass

Everyone has a bucket list for something. Die-hard bass anglers have many.

Leuenberger Air Service Is Your Ticket to Ontario's Best Fishing

Discover remote outpost fishing for northern pike, walleye, and whitefish

Four Fantastic Ontario Musky Waters

Discover 4 hotspots that any musky angler must add to their bucket list.

Top Flies for Northern Pike

Try These Go-to Flies and Tips on Your Next Trip

How To Stay Really Warm This Winter: the fingers, toes, ears, and nose edition

Must-wear items for staying warm—so you can enjoy your day on the ice!

Miles Bay Camp

Secluded fishing attracts anglers to Miles Bay on Lake of the Woods

Cat Island Lodge

Fly-in fishing for walleye and lake trout

Worm Your Way In

Try this go-to bait for bass on your next Northern Ontario angling adventure

Kicking It Old School

Dusting off the tin boat to fish less accessible waters