Trophy Deer Hunts

Gord Ellis uncovers one of Thunder Bay's most overlooked trophy hunts

One of Northwestern Ontario's most overlooked trophy deer hunting areas is tucked along the north shore of Lake Superior, close to Black Bay. There is bountiful Crown land here, some of it close to the highway, but most of it is located north of Highway 11/17. The key access points include the Dorion cut-off and Black Sturgeon Road, both accessed off the highway. A quick scan of Google Earth will reveal the maze of bush roads and power lines that crisscross the area.

The Dorion area is a mix of old forest, new cuts, and numerous waterways. However, there is also a smattering of farms and old homesteads that provide a lot of food for deer. Much of the farmland is private property and requires permission to hunt, but there are many deer in the Crown land that dominates the area.

deer trail cam
Tom Armstrong, the author’s frequent hunting partner, with a big Northwestern Ontario buck. (Photo credit: Gord Ellis)

It should be noted that Dorion bucks can have unusually dark and heavy antlers. Why the racks get so big here may have something to do with natural salt licks and mineral-rich spring creeks. This rich mineral loading helps grow large antlers. The extreme environment found here also seems to have been selected for very large-bodied deer. A typical mature buck will top 200 pounds on the hoof, and some really giant swamp monsters will push 300.

Hunting the Dorion area can be done in a variety of ways. There are plenty of open and semi-open areas to explore. Setting up on a power line and watching deer runways is an effective way to hunt for those who are patient. In cutovers, stalking and spotting with binoculars can pay off. Due to the nearly equal number of bucks to does, competition among the 'boys' is high. That's why rattling and calling can be very successful, especially in late October and early November, just before the main rut. Working the edges of forests and grassy beaver meadows with a set of small antlers and a grunt call can deliver a monster buck. Look for areas that have a large number of rubs on trees, the calling cards of bucks.

Many prefer to wait for the snow, as tracking bucks can be very effective in cuts. Although the air temperatures are often gnarly in late November and early December, that weather also gets the animals up and walking around. It's amazing how many large deer are shot the day after the first big snow.

If you are looking for an overlooked deer hunting area in the Northwest, The Dorion region is worth a look.

About Gord Ellis

Gord Ellis is a lifelong resident of Thunder Bay, Ontario and a full time journalist, broadcaster, professional angler and guide. He is the senior editor of Ontario Out of Doors magazine, Canada's best read fishing and hunting magazine. Gord is a regular on CBC radio's Superior Morning and writes a monthly column on Ontario for the Northern Wilds magazine, in Minnesota. He has written over a thousand feature articles and columns for publications as diverse as Sentier Chasse Peche, in Quebec, the Financial Post and the Globe and Mail. He is a long time member of the Outdoor Writers of Canada and has won better than 25 national awards for his writing and photography. In 2018, Gord was inducted into the Freshwater Fishing Hall of Fame in Hayward, Wisconsin.

Recommended Articles

Thunder Bay Birds

Hunting on the Mississippi Flyway

Big & Small

4 Hunts to do in Ontario that Don’t Include Whitetails

Ontario Waterfowl Hunt

Canada in the Rough hunts for waterfowl around Prince Edward County.

Moose Hunting in Ontario

Ontario is one of the best places to fulfill the dream.

Is an All Day Deer Hunt Worth It?

Paul Beasely shares his tips on how to succeed at the dreaded all-day sit.

5 Reasons to Hunt in Sunset Country

Hunt for deer, moose, black bear, and several small game and waterfowl.

Inside Deer Season

Learn the Four Major Whitetail Cycles

Wild Turkey & A Blind

A Ground Blind is An Exciting Way to Hunt

Bruce County Turkey

Sometimes It All Comes Together

A Bear of a Lifetime

I have been lucky to harvest a number of bears in my lifetime, but this bear truly made me speechless

First Class Duck Hunt

Avid Duck Hunters Should Hunt Walpole Island at Least Once

Archery Grouse

A dad reflects on his daughter's journey from young archer to experienced hunter and outdoor enthusiast.

Deer Hunting in Sunset Country

An overview of deer hunting in Northwestern Ontario—and what the future holds

A Heritage Hunt

Duck Hunting on Long Point Bay

Turkey Time

Shaking Off the Cabin Fever

A Duck Hunting Bonanza

Duck Hunting on Tthe mouth of the Thames River.

Father and Son Fly-in Moose Hunt

Scott Smith and his son visit Wilerness North in Ontario's Sunset Country

Hunting Water for Moose

A Thrilling Way to Fill a Tag in Ontario

Where Big Bucks Roam

Ontario's Sunset Country is a Hidden Gem

Spring Scouting

Making the Difference in the Upcoming Season