Big Surprise on Lake Ontario

The thrill of landing a remarkable catch.

*Originally published on October 24, 2017

It’s common knowledge even outside the fishing community that anglers are known to tell tall tales. It’s really no wonder since, when spending time on the water, some truly amazing or wild things can occur that you almost need to see to believe. It could be a unique wildlife encounter, the thrill of landing a remarkable catch, or the heartbreak of the one that got away, which almost always grows bigger in our minds. The more time spent on the water, the more stories there will be. Thankfully, today, with the popularity of cell phones and cameras, some of these moments can be realized with the ability to easily document them. As the saying goes, Pictures or it didn’t happen. Right?

A recent adventure was one I’ll never forget, and that certainly falls into the category above. To be honest, it started with some not-so-good luck for me. The day was young, and I had already lost three good fish while out trolling on Lake Ontario for walleye. A break-off, a pulled hook, and then a big walleye shaking the crankbait free right before entering the net. I felt like I was on a bad luck streak, and each fish was haunting me more than the last. These were good bites, and I am still a little haunted. I finally broke the streak with a nice little walleye. Shortly after, my fishing partner, Eric, hooked into something massive. He said it wasn’t fighting quite like the walleye we were after. One of my favourite places to fish, Lake Ontario, can sure offer up some surprise by-catches from time to time.

angler holding a walleye
(Photo credit: Ashley Rae)

Whatever Eric had on was peeling some serious line, and he couldn’t get much leverage on it at all. Slowing the boat down helped gain some ground on this fish. He was counting down the feet on the line counter reel aloud as the fish got closer to the boat. He tightened and loosened the drag, adjusting to the movement of the fish so as not to put too much pressure on, or offer too much slack. It’s a delicate balance in the heat of the moment.

As the line counter number dropped, I grabbed the net and leaned out the back, waiting to catch a glimpse as Eric reeled away. Moments later, it surfaced and…oh my goodness! We both saw it at once, the biggest pike we’ve laid eyes on in Ontario waters. The sight of it took my breath away.

angler holding northern pike
(Photo credit: Ashley Rae)

I leaned over the back of the boat, ready the net and waiting for the pike to come within scooping distance. As it came within reach, I slid the net underneath, at which point the fish shook, sinking both trebles of the Jointed Deep Husky Jerk into the net and simultaneously popping the hook out of its mouth. NO, NO, NO! I was now left with only the head of the pike in the net while its massive belly hung over the side. Any sudden movement, and this fish could break our hearts and make for a very long, quiet ride home. Eric was likely hollering from behind me at this point, but I couldn’t hear anything. I just had to get this fish in the net. I leaned over the transom as far as I could (contemplating jumping in if I had to) and dropped the net a bit, quickly sliding the rest of its body inside. PHEW!

It was an emotional rollercoaster that thankfully ended with cheering, high-fives, screaming, and hysterical laughter. This fish was a brute! I even struggled a little bit to lift the fish into the boat. I can’t even begin to tell you how relieved I was after my bad luck that day.

I snapped some quick photos before Eric sent his new personal best northern pike back into the cool Lake Ontario waters. We were both in awe, but wanted to get the fish back quickly. I know we will be looking back on these photos and admiring this fish again and again.

angler holding a northern pike

(Photo credit: Ashley Rae)

Finishing out the day, we both got into some walleye and a few more pike. I must say that was certainly the most dramatic and exciting pike experience I’ve ever had.

About Ashley Rae

Ashley Rae is a year-round multi-species angler residing in Ottawa, Ontario. She is a full-time fishing writer and content creator. Ashley is passionate about chasing anything with fins from her boat, kayak, from shore, or on the ice

Recommended Articles

Grand Tappattoo Resort: Fishing Adventures Near the GTA

A half-hour drive from Parry Sound = excellent pike and bass fishing.

Frequently Asked Questions About Grass Carp

Learn how to detect these fish species and how to keep them out of the Great Lakes.

The Big Bass List: 5 Incredible Hotspots in Northern Ontario

From hidden back bays of Sunset Country to the legendary "wolf packs" of Lake Huron.

Fishing Esnagi Lake

Train-in Fishing at Lodge Eighty Eight

Blue Heron Resort

Incredible smallmouth bass fishing on the lower Spanish River.

Eagle Lake Island Lodge: Your All-Inclusive Fishing Paradise

Nestled on a private island in the heart of Ontario's Sunset Country, Eagle Lake Island Lodge offers an unparalleled fishing experience.

Creating an Angler

Family Fishing in Northern Ontario

Top 5 Musky Destinations in Ontario

The Musky Hunter shows you where to land the best musky in Ontario waters.

The Spin on Early Season Walleye

Depending on where you are walleye fishing in Ontario, the conditions range from early spring to near summer-like.

The Lake With Giant Bass

Lake Lauzon has tons of bass to satisfy any dedicated bass angler.

Fishing The Shoulder Season

Incredible Smallmouth Bass and Northern Pike fishing at The Outpost Lodge in the Mississagi Valley

The Amazing Nipigon River

Fishing the river that is home to the world's largest brook trout ever caught.

Action-Packed Walleye, Bass, and Pike at Brennan Harbour Resort

Classic Canadian Fishing. Spectacular Lake Huron Views.

Fishing Dreams Come True

Five Ontario Fisheries Everyone Should Visit

This Smallmouth Bass Paradise Is No Longer A Secret

The Mississagi Valley has opportunities for personal best trophy-sized brown bass.

Fishing for Ontario Wild Brook Trout At Northern Skies Resort

Targeting wild brook in the local rivers, creeks and streams of Algoma Country, Ontario.

Smallmouth Bass With Still Water Fishing and Tours

For the pike and musky anglers, Lake Huron really shines bright.

Ontario Fly Fishing Hotspots

The Top 10 List from The New Fly Fisher TV Show.

Sliding Into Bass Heaven

Fall is approaching, and they need to start feeding for the winter.

Keystone Muskies

Fishing Tips for Targeting Muskie on Cedar Lake